Skip to main content
Atomic can help you create workflows. Ask it to turn a repeatable process into a tracked multi-stage workflow.

Workflows

Atomic uses workflows to run executable engineering loops: reusable multi-stage automation with tracked stages, parallel branches, artifacts, human input, live status, checkpoints, and resumable background execution. Default to a workflow for non-trivial work with a verifiable objective — see When to Use Workflows for the decision signals, execution shapes, and exceptions. Key capabilities:
  • Tracked stages - Name each step and inspect it in workflow status and graph views
  • Parallel branches - Run independent research, review, or implementation branches concurrently
  • Context handoffs - Pass summaries, artifacts, files, and schema-backed structured results between stages
  • Human input - Pause for ctx.ui.input, confirm, select, editor, or custom TUI widget decisions during a run
  • Resumable control - Interrupt, pause, quit, resume, or connect to workflow runs
  • Intercom run notifications - Deliver async run results and control notices (long-running, needs-attention, completed, failed) to a parent session over Intercom
  • Artifacts - Save large outputs to files instead of pushing everything through model context
  • Verification and gates - Preserve evidence, run checks, and stop for human approval where reliability matters
  • Model fallback chains - Retry important stages on fallback models when providers fail
  • Package distribution - Ship workflows through Atomic packages, settings, or conventional directories
Example use cases:
  • Well-defined autonomous jobs that benefit materially from durable execution state
  • Long-running or background work with explicit completion criteria
  • Codebase research with parallel local and external research stages
  • Review/fix loops with independent reviewers and a synthesis stage
  • Release planning with human approval gates
  • Documentation audits that save findings as artifacts
  • Multi-stage migrations, broad refactors, and validation/rollback plans
  • Reusable team workflows distributed through npm, git, or project settings

Table of Contents

Quick Start

To start a workflow quickly, describe it in natural language and let Atomic write it. If you’d rather write the TypeScript yourself, jump to Or hand-write the TypeScript below.

Just describe it

Describe the workflow you want in plain chat and Atomic will design and write it for you, using this page as its authoring reference:
For example:
Atomic will:
  • ask clarifying questions when stage purpose, inputs, models, or handoffs are ambiguous,
  • write a .atomic/workflows/<name>.ts file using workflow({...}),
  • pick ctx.task / ctx.chain / ctx.parallel / ctx.ui per the WorkflowContext primitives and task options reference,
  • use ctx.tool(name, args, fn) for workflow-owned side effects so completed operations are durably checkpointed and do not run again after resume (see ctx.tool),
  • run /workflow reload so Atomic rediscovers the workflow resource and you can launch it immediately.
You can also edit or harden an existing workflow in plain chat — ask Atomic to add a stage, switch a model, save artifacts, or wire in a human approval gate. List and run it like any other workflow:
Named workflow runs execute in the background. After launch, expect a run id and monitor it with /workflow status <run-id>, F2, or /workflow connect <run-id>. While a workflow is running, the visible below-editor BACKGROUND panel advances its elapsed label every second from the moment the run starts; it does not require opening or switching to the orchestrator. Updates repaint the existing mounted panel in place, paused timers stay frozen, and terminal cards retain their short recent-run expiry.

Or hand-write the TypeScript

Workflow files are plain TypeScript modules. Create .atomic/workflows/explain-file.ts:
Run /workflow reload or restart Atomic, then list and run it:
See Writing a Workflow for the full workflow({...}) API and WorkflowContext for ctx.task / ctx.chain / ctx.parallel / ctx.stage / ctx.ui.

When to Use Workflows

Workflows are the default execution path when a request is non-trivial or combines inherent structure with a verifiable objective — implementation, build, debugging, bug fixes, migrations, features, scoped multi-file edits, docs/code changes where validation matters, and work with dependencies, handoffs, review gates, uncertainty, measurable done criteria, or evidence requirements. Choose a workflow before direct chat when the prompt includes any of these signals:
  • implementation, build, debugging/diagnosis, bug-fix, migration, new-feature, scoped multi-file, or validated docs/code work
  • multiple subtasks, dependencies, handoffs, uncertainty, or parallel/sequential stages
  • review, validation, QA, approval, evidence, or human-input gates
  • long-running or resumable background execution, saved artifacts, or important model fallback chains
  • reusable automation or an explicit loop/stop condition (see the signal phrases below)
Loop or stop-condition phrasing is an especially strong workflow signal: do X until Y, repeat until, iterate until, review/fix until passing, run checks and fix until green, and keep going until done define control flow and convergence criteria that should be tracked. Use direct chat only for tiny, deterministic, low-risk answers or edits where stage tracking clearly costs more than it adds, typically a single-file/no-test/no-review change. Decide inline versus workflow before the first tool call; reconnaissance is already inline execution. Once workflow fit is clear, limit pre-workflow reconnaissance to the few reads needed to sharpen the objective and validation criteria, and put deeper research or behavior probing inside the run. Workflow-first does not require builtins, monolithic workflows, or a force-fit builtin: a builtin that matches 60% of the task and fights the other 40% is worse than a small custom graph. Discover named builtin, project, user, and package workflows; or author a task-specific TypeScript workflow({...}) inline with normal coding tools whenever the task needs richer branching, dynamic fan-out, artifacts, structured outputs, child workflows, human input, gates, retries, or loops. Rich custom workflows can compose the common workflow patterns: classify and branch at runtime, fan out and synthesize artifacts, run worker/verifier/reducer repair cycles, generate and filter or tournament-rank candidates, and loop until explicit evidence says the work is done. Workflow definitions are composable TypeScript modules — see Workflow Composition. Atomic can write the definition, reload workflow resources, and run it for the current task; the workflow tool has no create action. If inline work drifts past roughly ten exploratory tool calls without an artifact, edit, or commit, or repeats a “verify one more thing” loop, save the findings to a context file and hand the task to the best-fit named or custom workflow through reads. Sunk research is transferable, not a reason to continue inline.

Choosing an Execution Shape

“Use a workflow” is not one decision — it covers several execution shapes with different costs and guarantees. This section is written as agent-facing guidance: it is the self-prompt an orchestrating agent should run before the first tool call on a new request, and it doubles as documentation for humans who want to steer that choice explicitly. The shapes, cheapest first:

The self-prompt

Ask these questions in order and stop at the first shape that satisfies every remaining requirement. Decide before the first tool call and state the decision; reconnaissance already counts as inline execution.
  1. Is the outcome provable? If success can be stated as evidence (tests green, artifact exists, behavior demonstrated, reviewer approves), the task fits a workflow. If no proof is possible or needed, inline is probably fine.
  2. Is there structure? Multiple subtasks, dependencies, handoffs, or parallel slices rule out inline execution. A single focused evidence-gathering pass does not.
  3. Is there a loop or gate? Any “until Y”, “fix until passing”, review/approval gate, or unknown-length repair cycle requires a workflow that enforces the stop condition, never an improvised inline retry loop or a stretched subagent chain.
  4. Is it one task or a queue of tasks? “Address all open issues” or “fix every ticket assigned to me” is a factory request, not one workflow. Enumerate and dependency-classify the items first, then follow Task queues and software factories: independent items become separate per-item runs; dependent items share one composed graph.
  5. Does an installed graph already fit? If a named workflow’s objective and inputs cover essentially the whole task, run it. Do not force-fit a partial match (When to Use Workflows).
  6. Does the control flow need shapes builtins don’t offer? Runtime classification, per-item dynamic fan-out, generate-and-filter, tournaments, or domain-specific gates mean authoring a custom workflow from the common workflow patterns.
  7. Does a proven graph already solve a sub-problem? Nest it with ctx.workflow(...) instead of re-authoring its prompts and gates. Use composition instead of duplication whenever you can cleanly map the child’s input/output contract.
  8. Is it only specialist evidence-gathering? If the parent keeps control, no completion gate is needed, and the work is bounded (a debug pass, a parallel research fanout, one noisy investigation), inline subagents are enough — and cheaper than a workflow.
  9. Is it truly tiny? Deterministic, low-risk, single-file/no-test/no-review — answer or edit inline and stop.

Scoring rubric

When the ladder is ambiguous, score the task on six dimensions (0–2 each): Interpretation:
  • 0–3 total: inline. Adding stages creates more work than value.
  • 4–6 total, Iteration ≤ 1, no gate: inline subagents when the parent should retain control, or a small named/custom workflow when tracking and artifacts matter.
  • 7+ total, or Iteration = 2, or Verifiability = 2 with a review/approval gate: a real workflow. Prefer a named workflow when one fits the whole task; otherwise author a custom graph, nesting proven children where sub-problems overlap.
  • Any single hard signal overrides the arithmetic: an explicit loop/stop condition, an approval or evidence gate, or a request for durable/background execution puts the task in workflow territory regardless of total score.
The rubric prevents two common misuses: using parent-controlled subagent calls for an ad hoc implement→review→retry pipeline (that is adversarial verification without an engine — use a workflow and let its stages delegate specialists), and unbounded inline reconnaissance — apply the ten-call rule from When to Use Workflows: save findings to a context file and hand off through reads.

Task queues and software factories

Some requests are not one task but a queue of them: “address all open issues”, “fix every Linear ticket assigned to me”, “burn down the TODO backlog”, “upgrade every service to the new SDK”. These fire-and-forget factory requests need a separate decision step because one monolithic workflow would process the queue serially in a single growing context. Triage the queue before choosing the shape. The first action is always a cheap enumeration-and-dependency pass, not implementation: list the items (issue tracker query, ticket API, grep for TODOs), then classify how they relate:
  • Independent items — different subsystems, no shared files, no ordering constraints, each individually verifiable.
  • Dependent items — one blocks another, they touch the same files/modules, they share a migration or API change, or their acceptance criteria reference each other.
  • Clustered — the queue splits into groups: dependencies inside a group, independence between groups.
Independent items → many small runs, not one big one. Spawn one workflow run per item (typically goal with the item’s text as the objective and acceptance criteria, create_pr=true for per-item PRs), each in its own git_worktree_dir, running in the background. One run per item provides what a monolith cannot:
  • Isolation: a hard item that stalls or fails does not affect the remaining ones; each run resumes, retries, or can be stopped independently.
  • Clean contexts: every item starts with fresh context focused on its own objective instead of receiving the transcripts of twenty finished tickets.
  • Independent evidence: per-item reviewer gates, receipts, and PRs that a human can merge or reject one at a time.
  • Real parallelism: runs proceed concurrently, up to the number you choose to run at once (worktrees prevent filesystem collisions).
Dispatch a bounded number at a time (for example 3–5 concurrent runs), wait for lifecycle notices, then dispatch the next wave — and report the dispatch plan (item → run id → worktree) so the queue is auditable. Dependent items → one graph that encodes the ordering. When items block each other or share a change surface, isolation no longer helps — separate runs could modify the same files or rely on outdated assumptions. Encode the dependency structure explicitly instead:
  • A composed parent workflow that nests a proven child (for example ctx.workflow(goal, ...) per item) in dependency order, passing each item’s outputs/artifacts to its dependents — the preferred form, because each item still gets its own bounded loop and reviewer gate while the parent owns sequencing.
  • A single monolithic workflow only when the items share enough dependencies to form one task with subtasks (one migration touching every call site is one task, not a queue).
Clustered queues → both. Compose within a cluster, fan out across clusters: each cluster becomes one run (a composed parent or a single goal objective covering the cluster), and independent clusters are dispatched as parallel background runs in waves. The self-prompt for factory requests, condensed: enumerate → classify dependencies → fan out runs where independent, compose graphs where dependent → dispatch in bounded waves → report the plan. When dependency classification is uncertain, prefer smaller independent runs and let per-item reviewer gates catch collisions — a rejected PR is cheaper than a monolith that applied a bad assumption throughout the queue.

Prompting the choice

Humans can steer the shape directly. The most direct controls, in rough order of effect:
  • Name the shape or workflow. “Do this inline”, “use subagents to investigate”, “run the goal workflow”, or “write a custom workflow for this” overrides the agent’s own scoring.
  • State acceptance criteria. Verbatim acceptance criteria make the objective provable, which both selects workflow execution and sets the immutable contract that goal/ralph reviewers enforce.
  • State the loop. “Iterate until tests pass”, “review and fix until approved” — loop wording is a hard workflow signal and defines the stop condition.
  • State the evidence. Asking for a PR, a QA video, test output, or reviewer sign-off tells the agent which gates the graph needs.
  • State the boundary. “Work in a separate worktree”, “don’t create the PR yet”, or “stop after implementation” separates the implementation loop from explicitly authorized final actions.
  • State the queue policy. For factory requests, say how to split and gate the queue: “one workflow and PR per issue”, “these three tickets depend on each other — do them in order in one run”, “triage first and show me the dependency plan before dispatching”, or “no more than three runs at a time”. Absent a policy, the agent triages dependencies itself and defaults to independent per-item runs with per-item evidence.
Absent these levers, the agent applies the self-prompt and rubric above — so a prompt that mentions none of them is delegating the shape decision, not avoiding it.

Atomic vs Claude Code Dynamic Workflows

Claude Code Dynamic Workflows and Atomic address a similar problem: important software engineering work is too large for one agent pass, so the system should split the job into stages, run agents in parallel, verify the result, and keep enough state to finish long-running work. Atomic’s category is broader and more explicit: it is the loop engine for engineering work. The difference is who controls the process and how much of the loop you can inspect, version, extend, and connect to your stack.

Built-in Workflows

Atomic bundles ten workflows: four established end-to-end workflows and six reusable implementations of the common workflow patterns. They are available in every session — no install step required. Use /workflow list to confirm they are loaded, and /workflow inputs <name> to see the exact inputs in your environment. Workflow authors can also use these builtins as workflow definitions. Import them from @bastani/workflows/builtin and pass the definition directly to ctx.workflow(...) when one workflow should call deep-research-codebase, goal, ralph, open-claude-design, or any of the six pattern builtins as a nested child workflow. See Workflow Composition for full examples alongside user-defined child workflows. For the builtin result tables below, deep-research-codebase, goal, and ralph explicitly declare outputs: { result: Type.Optional(Type.String(...)) }, so result is an optional part of their declared output contracts and may be omitted, including after an intentional early exit. Like every workflow output, result must be declared in outputs and returned from run or supplied to ctx.exit({ outputs }) when present — see Outputs; Atomic adds no automatic result output.

Six composable pattern builtins

The six patterns in Pattern diagrams ship as full definitions exported from @bastani/workflows/builtin. Each has typed/defaulted inputs and declared outputs a parent can consume: Run them by name with /workflow <name> ... or import their definitions:
All six can be nested with ctx.workflow(definition, { inputs, stageName }) and count toward maxDepth (default four workflow levels). Prefer composing these definitions over copying their prompts or graphs: nested children contribute their stages, dedicated prompts, gates, artifacts, HIL nodes, and declared outputs to the expanded parent graph. A migration parent can wrap a fan-out-and-synthesize fix pass in loop-until-done while tests fail, then invoke adversarial-verification for each resulting patch; the parent consumes declared artifact paths and decisions rather than recreating the three graphs. Concrete migration composition:
The parent can consume every child’s precise declared outputs and can call adversarialVerification once per patch when its own typed input enumerates patch artifacts.

deep-research-codebase

Inputs: Run examples:
Workflow tool call:
Output locations and result fields: People can read, commit, or share the dated Markdown report. The hidden artifact directory keeps large scout, history, and specialist handoff files available for audit without cluttering the visible research index.

goal

Inputs: goal defaults to 10 worker/review turns. Reviewer quorum is fixed internally at 2 reviewer complete votes, and approval is deterministic on each reviewer’s self-reported stop_review_loop boolean: a reviewer approves exactly when it returns stop_review_loop=true with no reviewer_error (schema-parse failures count as non-approval), and the reducer completes the run when quorum of those booleans is met without recomputing approval from findings arrays or traceability statuses. The repeated-blocker threshold defaults to 3 consecutive same-blocker turns and is clamped to max_turns when you run fewer than 3 turns. Run examples:
goal uses the raw objective exactly as supplied as the operative objective recorded in the ledger and stores acceptance_criteria as the immutable literal contract (defaulting to the objective when omitted); it does not run an initial prompt-refinement stage. It creates an OS-temp goal-ledger.json artifact, renders goal-continuation context for each worker turn, writes the latest worker receipt to worker-receipt.md, and appends receipts, reviewer decisions, blockers, reducer decisions, and lifecycle events to the ledger. Worker and reviewer prompts (and the model-facing ledger artifact) deliberately omit the current turn/attempt number so the worker focuses on completing the objective rather than pacing itself to the workflow budget. Worker and reviewer prompts treat the objective as user-provided data, not higher-priority instructions. By default goal does not start the final pull-request stage, and pr_report is omitted. Prompt text alone does not opt in. Pass create_pr=true only when you explicitly want the final stage to inspect provider credentials and attempt provider-appropriate PR/MR/review creation, such as GitHub gh, Azure Repos az repos pr create, or Sapling/Phabricator tooling, after Goal reaches complete within max_turns. Goal worker and reviewer prompts explicitly tell intermediate stages to ignore PR-creation requests; only the final pull-request stage may attempt that handoff. Set git_worktree_dir when you want Goal’s worker and reviewer stages isolated in a reusable Git worktree. Relative paths resolve from the invoking repository root, existing same-repository worktree roots are reused, and missing paths are created from base_branch. Goal preserves the invoking repo-relative cwd inside the worktree, so launching from repo/packages/api with git_worktree_dir=../repo-wt runs stages from ../repo-wt/packages/api. If the run is resumed later with /workflow resume, Atomic reuses the original invocation cwd and recorded reusable-worktree metadata instead of resolving the worktree path from the resumed chat’s current cwd. Slow Git subprocesses can run for up to 60 seconds before Atomic reports an explicit Git timeout diagnostic. Write the objective as a compact acceptance spec. Define the desired end state, required testing, relevant commands or manual checks, and the outcome that proves completion. The workflow is intentionally lean: it does not first generate an RFC or migration plan, so the developer-supplied objective is where scope, validation, and completion criteria belong. Goal worker/reviewer prompts treat the objective and acceptance criteria as the sole literal source of truth: if follow-up deltas, language specs, upstream issues, in-repo comments, or best practices conflict with explicit wording, reviewers surface the conflict instead of silently implementing external knowledge. Reviewer findings carry objective_alignment (required_by_objective, consistent_with_objective, beyond_objective, or contradicts_objective); beyond_objective and contradicts_objective findings are reported but do not block completion and must not be promoted into follow-up objectives without reconciling them against the acceptance criteria. Severity labels alone never dismiss objective-relevant findings: required_by_objective findings block at any priority (P3 included), while consistent_with_objective P3 nice-to-haves stay non-blocking. Review decisions also include requirements_traceability, a clause-by-clause evidence map over every explicit objective/acceptance-criteria requirement. Findings and traceability are audit evidence that drive how each reviewer derives its authoritative stop_review_loop boolean; the harness gates approval on that boolean alone, and Goal tells reviewers that process-only clauses (reviewer quorum/approval counts, and the authorized post-approval PR/MR/review final action when create_pr=true) must never hold the flag at false. Passing worker-authored tests or snapshots alone is circular evidence unless tied to independent current-state proof. The worker may claim readiness, but it cannot finalize completion. Before implementing, Goal prompts the worker to derive an observable acceptance/contract matrix from the literal objective/acceptance criteria (one row per clause, each mapped to the concrete check that proves it) and to model states, transitions, and invariants explicitly when the work is stateful. Goal consolidates the latest reviewer findings into a deduplicated cross-reviewer batch persisted in the round artifact (consolidated_findings in review-round-latest.json), and the next worker prompt instructs the worker to plan and repair the whole batch — with durable regression evidence for reproduced findings — rather than fixing one finding per turn. Goal prompts workers and reviewers to verify user-visible behavior end-to-end when practical, using playwright-cli-skilled subagents for web/frontend flows that may depend on backend/API behavior and tmux-skilled subagents for TUI or terminal-app scenarios. They must assume credentials/auth/environment access exists until concrete checks plus an actual app/flow launch attempt prove otherwise; reviewers accept skipped E2E only when the worker records the exact attempted commands and observed failure output. Goal reviewers also look for any QA E2E video referenced by the ledger or receipt and must inspect the actual video before treating it as proof. Three reviewers independently inspect the ledger, worker receipt, repository state, and diff against base_branch; each starts in a clean, non-forked context, matching Ralph’s reviewer context behavior, and every Goal reviewer uses Ralph’s reviewer-a model chain with Claude Fable 5 as the primary model. Goal instructs each reviewer to first derive its own adversarial check list from the literal contract — boundary/edge/negative probes plus state/transition/invariant probes — before relying on the worker receipt or worker-authored tests, and each returns structured JSON with findings, evidence, verification still remaining, and an optional blocker. A TypeScript reducer marks the goal complete when reviewer quorum approves via the stop_review_loop booleans, marks blocked only when the same dependency/tool blocker repeats for the blocker threshold, continues while quorum is missing (recording the reviewers’ remaining work in the decision reason), and returns needs_human when max_turns is exhausted or worker execution fails, so the bounded loop always stops with an inspectable reason. At the start of every Goal review, each concurrent reviewer uses Intercom to initialize/check coordination and discover the sibling reviewers in the same workflow run. Before validation, reviewers communicate their plans and intended ownership, claim expensive or lock-prone checks, and serialize commands that can conflict in a shared checkout or environment, including full test suites, build or test commands, package-manager operations, browser/E2E sessions, migrations, and generated-artifact steps. They announce each coordinated check’s start and completion, release every claimed resource and send siblings an explicit resource-release update, and share reusable command outcomes/evidence where appropriate. This operational coordination prevents collisions and duplicate conflicting work; it does not replace independent patch inspection, analysis, or each reviewer’s own verdict. When Goal’s reducer returns needs_human, blocked, or another incomplete status, Atomic does not report the top-level workflow run as successful. /workflow status and lifecycle notices surface it as blocked/failed according to the run’s terminal condition. Atomic also preserves structured recoverable failure metadata from the run’s blocking stage (failedStageId) or run-level failure metadata, so auth, rate-limit, and provider fallback exhaustion remains blocked/resumable even if the workflow later returns ordinary outputs instead of a reserved status value. Tolerated branch failures from non-fail-fast parallel work do not reclassify an otherwise completed run. Each Goal review round persists a convergence summary. Each reviewer record and review artifact distinguishes schema-parse status from the review verdict with parsed, approved, stopReviewLoop, nextAction, finalActionRemaining, and diagnostics fields; each reports malformed or missing structured reviewer output as a parse failure rather than as an ordinary finding/rejection. When create_pr=true, reviewers are told that PR/MR/review creation is a post-approval final action: if implementation and validation requirements are proven and only PR creation remains, the implementation can approve with finalActionRemaining: true and nextAction: "pull-request" instead of consuming another worker turn. The ledger’s reducer decision repeats the same concise fields for the controller outcome, so a successful quorum records approved: true, stopReviewLoop: true, and nextAction: "pull-request" when create_pr=true (otherwise "finish") before any final handoff runs. Result fields:

ralph

Inputs: Run examples:
Each ralph run uses the raw prompt exactly as supplied as the operative objective for research, orchestration, and review, and stores acceptance_criteria as the immutable literal contract (defaulting to the prompt when omitted). Shared literal-contract prompt language forbids adding behaviors, restrictions, or error conditions beyond the prompt/acceptance criteria and requires surfacing conflicts with external knowledge; Ralph does not run an initial prompt-refinement stage. Each iteration transforms that raw prompt with /skill:prompt-engineer Transform the following user request into a codebase and online research question which can be thoroughly explored: ... (research-prompt-refinement), researches that transformed question with /skill:research-codebase ..., and writes the findings under research/. The research, orchestrator, and reviewer prompts carry acceptance_criteria next to the literal contract, so orchestrators should pass the ORIGINAL task text when launching follow-up Ralph runs from reviewer findings. Before implementing, Ralph prompts the orchestrator to derive an observable acceptance/contract matrix from the literal prompt/acceptance criteria (one row per clause mapped to the concrete observable check that proves it) and to model states, transitions, and invariants explicitly when the work is stateful. It treats the research artifact as its primary implementation context, initializes/updates an OS-temp implementation notes file while generating verifiable evidence for any claims it records in the notes and reviewer artifacts, delegates implementation through sub-agents, repairs unresolved reviewer findings as one consolidated batch (with durable regression evidence for reproduced findings) rather than one finding per iteration, and asks two independent reviewers (reviewer-a and reviewer-b) to inspect the patch directly against base_branch. The reviewer fan-out runs reviewers on different primary model families (Claude Fable 5 and GPT-5.5 Codex, with shared fallbacks) so the adversarial review gets cross-model coverage instead of repeated passes from one model, and Ralph instructs each reviewer to first derive its own adversarial check list from the literal contract — boundary/edge/negative probes plus state/transition/invariant probes — before relying on the implementation notes, orchestrator report, or worker-authored tests. Ralph prompts its orchestrator and reviewers to verify user-visible behavior end-to-end when practical, using playwright-cli-skilled subagents for web/frontend flows that may depend on backend/API behavior and tmux-skilled subagents for TUI or terminal-app scenarios. They must assume credentials/auth/environment access exists until concrete checks plus an actual app/flow launch attempt prove otherwise; reviewers accept skipped E2E only when the orchestrator records the exact attempted commands and observed failure output. For UI-applicable or full-stack changes, the orchestrator runs a playwright-cli end-to-end QA pass and records a reviewable proof video (referenced in the implementation notes and surfaced as qa_video_path); reviewers receive that path and must inspect the actual video before treating it as proof. When create_pr=true, the final pull-request stage attaches or links that video to the created PR/MR/review after reviewer approval. If reviewers find issues, the next research-prompt-refinement and research stages receive the review artifact path (whose review-round-latest.json carries a deduplicated cross-reviewer consolidated_findings batch) so follow-up research can address unresolved findings, and research stages fork from prior research session data when available. The loop stops only when both reviewers independently approve or max_loops is reached, so the bounded loop always stops with an inspectable review round. Ralph findings include the same objective_alignment classification used by Goal, and each reviewer derives a single authoritative stop_review_loop boolean from that evidence: required_by_objective findings mean false at any priority (P3 included, because severity labels alone never dismiss objective-relevant findings), consistent_with_objective P0/P1/P2 findings mean false while P3 remains a non-blocking nice-to-have, and beyond_objective/contradicts_objective findings are surfaced but non-blocking so they are not silently converted into new requirements. The loop gate approves deterministically on stop_review_loop=true plus a null reviewer_error (parse failures count as non-approval) without recomputing approval from the findings arrays. Ralph review decisions also include requirements_traceability, a clause-by-clause evidence map over every explicit prompt/acceptance-criteria requirement kept as audit evidence for deriving the flag; reviewers are explicitly told that process-only clauses (reviewer quorum, and the authorized post-approval PR/MR/review final action when create_pr=true) must never hold the flag at false. Passing worker-authored tests or snapshots is circular evidence unless tied to independent current-state proof. By default Ralph does not start the final pull-request stage, and pr_report is omitted. Prompt text alone does not opt in. Pass create_pr=true only when you explicitly want the final pull-request stage to inspect provider credentials and attempt provider-appropriate PR/MR/review creation, such as GitHub gh, Azure Repos az repos pr create, or Sapling/Phabricator tooling; Ralph’s own PR-creation instructions live in that final stage and run only after approval. At the start of every Ralph review, each concurrent reviewer uses Intercom to initialize/check coordination and discover the sibling reviewer in the same workflow run. Before validation, reviewers communicate their plans and intended ownership, claim expensive or lock-prone checks, and serialize commands that can conflict in a shared checkout or environment, including full test suites, build or test commands, package-manager operations, browser/E2E sessions, migrations, and generated-artifact steps. They announce each coordinated check’s start and completion, release every claimed resource and send the sibling an explicit resource-release update, and share reusable command outcomes/evidence where appropriate. This operational coordination prevents collisions and duplicate conflicting work; it does not replace independent patch inspection, analysis, or each reviewer’s own verdict. Each Ralph review artifact and review-round-latest.json includes a convergence_decision summary with parsed, approved, stopReviewLoop, nextAction, finalActionRemaining, and diagnostics. This distinguishes malformed or missing structured reviewer output from a parsed reviewer rejection or blocking finding by reporting it as a parse failure. When create_pr=true, reviewers are told that PR/MR/review creation is a post-approval final action: if implementation and validation requirements are proven and only PR creation remains, the implementation can approve with finalActionRemaining: true and nextAction: "pull-request" instead of consuming another orchestration iteration. When both reviewers converge, the latest round records approved: true, stopReviewLoop: true, and nextAction: "pull-request" when create_pr=true (otherwise "finish"), and the implementation loop stops before the final handoff stage. Set git_worktree_dir when you want Ralph’s worker stages isolated in a reusable Git worktree. Relative paths resolve from the invoking repository root, existing same-repository worktree roots are reused, and missing paths are created from base_branch. Ralph preserves the invoking repo-relative cwd inside the worktree, so launching from repo/packages/api with git_worktree_dir=../repo-wt runs stages from ../repo-wt/packages/api. Result fields: For a delegated autonomous implementation that materially benefits from a durable research-first pipeline, use /skill:research-codebase/skill:create-spec/workflow ralph prompt="Implement specs/2026-03-rate-limit.md and validate the documented burst behavior". Ralph can start from a spec path, GitHub issue, or crisp ticket description; it uses that prompt as-is, researches the task, delegates through sub-agents, reviews, records a QA proof video for UI/full-stack changes when practical, and iterates. Use /workflow goal when an autonomous job instead materially benefits from a durable goal ledger, bounded worker turns, and reviewer-gated completion; give it a concrete objective and add create_pr=true only when you want Goal’s final pull-request stage after approval. Task size alone does not select either workflow.

open-claude-design

Inputs: The output type (prototype, wireframe, page, component, theme, tokens) and any reference designs are not inputs — the discovery stage asks for them. There is no design_system input; the workflow establishes or loads the project’s DESIGN.md/PRODUCT.md automatically. Result fields: open-claude-design has no result output; it exposes only the declared fields listed above. Use the declared artifact and handoff fields for generated content. Combined discovery/init. The workflow’s first and only front-door stage runs /skill:impeccable shape and /skill:impeccable init together. It interviews you (via the structured question tool) about what you want to build, the output type (prototype, wireframe, page, component, theme, or tokens), and which references to emulate (URLs, local file paths, screenshots, or design docs). Then, in the same discovery stage, impeccable init detects PRODUCT.md/DESIGN.md and creates or reconciles those files as needed. The references you name take precedence over DESIGN.md/PRODUCT.md during generation (the design system fills gaps the references don’t cover, and PRODUCT.md still governs strategic register/voice). Headless runs infer a defensible brief, output type, references, and project-context assumptions rather than blocking. Context and reference phase. Design-system/reference research runs first, then gallery reference discovery uses those findings before the generator consumes the combined context:
  • Design-system/reference research — three parallel passes (ds-locator / ds-analyzer / ds-patterns) extract the project’s design-system evidence and also handle user-provided references. URL references are captured with browser/screenshot tooling where available; local files, screenshots, and design docs are parsed by the applicable ds-* pass. Their extracted requirements feed the generator and take precedence over DESIGN.md/PRODUCT.md. There are no separate web-capture-*, file-parser-*, or design-system-builder stages.
  • Reference discovery (gated by discover_references=true, the default) — after the ds-* passes complete, the reference-discovery stage receives their evidence plus the PRODUCT.md/DESIGN.md init summary.
    • It uses the playwright-cli skill to browse five curated galleries: Awwwards, recent.design, Dribbble recents, Monet, and Motionsites.
    • It then opens the strongest selected designs and, ideally, records a scroll-through video of each real design page so its animations are captured. A full-page screenshot is a supplement or fallback, and the real destination URL is retained; it does not just screenshot gallery thumbnails, with web search as the fallback when the browser is unavailable.
    • It asks which curated reference direction you prefer. If none align, it asks you to provide a reference image, screenshot, URL, or local path for best results.
    • The workflow persists the curated references brief to <artifact_dir>/references.md and passes it to the generator (reference_inspiration) and refinement. Set discover_references=false to skip it.
Generate/user-feedback loop. Refinement is intentionally simple and mirrors Ralph’s implement/reviewer rhythm: generate-1 writes the first preview.html, user-feedback-1 opens that preview with /skill:impeccable live, and any captured live_changes, user_notes, or annotated_snapshot feed the next forked generate-* stage. Generator and feedback stages keep separate session lineages: each later generate-* forks from the previous generate session, user-feedback-1 starts its own feedback chain, and each later user-feedback-* forks only from the previous feedback session rather than falling back to generator sessions. When a user-feedback-* stage captures no meaningful feedback, the loop exports immediately. The workflow deliberately runs only exporter, followed by final-display; there is no pre-export scan, forced-fix stage, or export gate. The workflow saves captured feedback as durable artifacts under <artifact_dir>/feedback/iteration-<n>.md / .json (plus a best-effort copy of the annotated snapshot, constrained to files within the project/artifact dir). If captured notes fail to thread into the next generate prompt, the run fails with an explicit error rather than silently generating without user feedback. Browser requirement. open-claude-design is browser-centric (the discovery/preview review and the live QA loop need the playwright-cli skill’s browser). If no browser is available, the workflow exits cleanly before generation and reports the would-be artifact paths and install instructions rather than generating a design you could not review interactively. (The test harness skips this early exit so headless test runs still complete.) Run examples:
The discovery interview asks for the output type and any reference URLs/files, so do not pass output_type, reference, or design_system on the command line.

Launching with natural language

You can also start a built-in workflow by describing the task in chat. Atomic picks the matching workflow and fills in inputs from your request:
If required inputs are missing or ambiguous, Atomic asks for missing inputs or opens the inline input picker before launching. Named workflows run in the background with a run id. See Running Workflows for launch behavior, Workflow Commands for the common controls, and Monitor and Control Runs for steering, pausing, and resuming.

Writing a Workflow

Workflow files are TypeScript modules that export a workflow definition:
Authoring basics:
  • workflow({ ... }) returns the workflow definition directly for discovery; there is no builder terminal step.
  • Workflow names normalize for lookup: trim, lowercase, convert whitespace/underscore to hyphen, remove other punctuation, and collapse hyphens.
  • description sets the listing text.
  • inputs declares typed user inputs.
  • worktreeFromInputs optionally maps input names to workflow-wide reusable Git worktree defaults.
  • outputs declares typed outputs that parent workflows receive from ctx.workflow(childWorkflow, ...).
  • run: async (ctx) => { ... } defines the workflow body.
To migrate an existing file from the removed defineWorkflow(...).compile() builder, see Migrating from the defineWorkflow() Builder API for the full method-to-key mapping, a before/after walkthrough, and a conversion checklist. prompt and task are aliases for task text inside authored workflow primitives. Prefer prompt because it mirrors lower-level stage.prompt(...); task remains useful in ctx.chain(...) examples. Author workflows to create at least one tracked stage by calling ctx.task(), ctx.chain(), ctx.parallel(), ctx.stage(), or ctx.workflow() in the run body so each normal run has graph nodes to inspect, attach to, interrupt, resume, and render. Guard-only workflows may call ctx.exit(...) before creating a stage when they intentionally stop early.

Guiding Principles

  • Locally scoped stage prompts - Describe only the current stage’s objective, inputs, expected outputs, and success criteria. Avoid references to other stages unless the current stage explicitly receives and needs that information, and avoid workflow-specific or stage-specific vocabulary that is not explained inside the current prompt. See Locally Scoped Stage Prompts for the expanded contract.
  • Clear vocabulary - Use clear software engineering terminology in self-described prompts.
  • No regex gates - Avoid hard-coded regular expressions that gate reviews or model outputs.
  • Schema-backed gates - Prefer schema-backed workflow stages (ctx.stage(..., { schema }), ctx.chain items, or ctx.parallel items) for review/gate decisions whenever the workflow must evaluate model output; a schema-enabled item receives the structured-output tool automatically. See Evaluation and Quality Gates.
  • Stages are model stages - Treat atomic workflow units as language model stages, not deterministic tools.
  • Small deterministic-gate stages - When deterministic gates are needed, create small dedicated stages that instruct a model to run a specific tool or perform a specific check. This keeps gates adaptive to the current codebase while preserving explicit workflow structure.
  • Checkpoint workflow-owned side effects - Prefer ctx.tool(name, args, fn) for filesystem writes, network mutations, external API actions, and other side effects orchestrated directly by the workflow definition. Atomic durably caches a completed call’s serializable result, so resume returns that result without rerunning fn. Keep pure computation and side-effect-free transformations as ordinary TypeScript. Do not wrap agent-stage internals or every function call indiscriminately.

Context engineering guidance

Also document the context that stages pass to one another:
  • For substantial handoffs, create files or artifacts and tell the next stage to read them instead of putting large text outputs in its prompt or context.
  • Prefer forked context for non-reviewer stages so long-running implementation work keeps a coherent, continuous context.
  • Prefer a clean context window for reviewer stages so earlier implementation stages do not bias the reviewer. Reviewers should evaluate the supplied artifacts, changed files, tests, and explicit criteria as independently as possible.
See Context Engineering for details.

Inputs

Inputs are declared with TypeBox Type.* schemas in the inputs object. Import Type from typebox directly in workflow files. Workflow packages still declare typebox as a peer dependency so TypeBox schemas resolve under tsc — see Programmatic Usage. Common input schemas map to picker kinds and accepted runtime values: A Type.Union([Type.Literal(...)]) of string literals expresses a ‘select’: the input picker renders those literals as choices, and runtime validation rejects values outside them. Put description and default in the schema options object, e.g. Type.String({ description: "…", default: "…" }). An input is required when its schema is not wrapped in Type.Optional(...) and declares no default; wrap optional inputs in Type.Optional(...). A default does not make an input optional — a defaulted input is always present after defaults are applied. Prefer explicit descriptions because /workflow inputs <name>, /workflow <name> --help, and the input picker show these descriptions to users. Runtime validation uses TypeBox Value and is strict for both top-level named runs and ctx.workflow(...) child calls: Atomic rejects unknown keys, missing required values, type mismatches, non-JSON-serializable values, and union/literal values outside the declared choices before the workflow body starts. It does not coerce strings like "3" to numbers; pass count=3 or JSON numbers when a schema declares Type.Number(). In TypeScript workflow files, entries in inputs also narrow ctx.inputs for better intellisense: required/defaulted Type.String() inputs are string, Type.Number() is number, Type.Boolean() is boolean, a Type.Union([Type.Literal(...)]) select is the literal string union, and Type.Optional(...) inputs include undefined. Use Static<typeof schema> when you need the inferred TypeScript type of a schema directly.

Outputs

Workflow outputs are runtime contracts for completed workflow runs and for parent workflows that call a child with ctx.workflow(childWorkflow, ...). A workflow normally returns a JSON-serializable object from run, and entries in the outputs object document, validate, and expose keys from that returned object. ctx.exit({ outputs }) can expose a partial subset of the same declared output contract when the run intentionally stops early. Primitives, arrays, null, functions, symbols, undefined properties, NaN, and infinite numbers fail validation. Return convention: outputs are return-object keys. Atomic never infers child workflow outputs from stage names, stage order, or the final assistant message. If a parent should read child.outputs.foo, the child workflow’s run must both declare outputs: { foo: schema } and return { foo: value }. result is not special, and Atomic never adds it: to expose result, declare it in outputs and return { result } exactly like any other output. Returning a key that is not declared in outputs fails the run with atomic-workflows: workflow "<name>" returned undeclared output "<key>"; declare it in outputs or remove it from the run return. Reserved status output convention and structured failures: if a workflow declares and returns a top-level status output with the string value "failed", Atomic treats the run as failed instead of recording a successful completion. Returned "blocked", "needs_human", "incomplete", "active", and "auth_blocked" statuses are treated as blocked/incomplete terminal states rather than successful completions. Independently of that convention, Atomic uses structured failure metadata captured from the run’s blocking stage (failedStageId) or run-level failure metadata to keep recoverable auth, rate-limit, and provider fallback exhaustion blocked/resumable even when the workflow did not declare a status output. Atomic does not infer failure state by scanning arbitrary output text or by scanning every failed stage in an otherwise completed non-fail-fast branch. When a workflow returns a reserved status, Atomic uses a non-empty top-level summary string as the run reason shown in lifecycle notices and status surfaces; if no non-empty value is present, Atomic falls back to non-empty top-level remaining_work and then result text. Use the reserved status convention only when the workflow is intentionally reporting its own terminal state (for example, a deterministic release gate that returns { status: "blocked", summary: "required checks are pending" }, or a reviewer-gated workflow that returns { status: "needs_human", remaining_work: "provider credentials are missing" }). Do not use a top-level status field for unrelated external state such as a deployment/check the workflow only inspected; choose a domain-specific name like deployment_status or gate_status instead. The outputs object is a schema contract, not an automatic stage selector. To expose values from any stage, capture the stage/task/child result in normal TypeScript and return it from run under the desired key:
Atomic never adds a result output. A workflow exposes only the keys it declares in outputs and returns from run. To expose result, declare outputs: { result: schema } and return { result }. Returning a key not declared in outputs fails with the returned undeclared output error quoted above. For a child workflow call, <name> is the child’s name, and the parent surfaces the failure through the child-failure wrapper described in Workflow Composition. Outputs are declared with TypeBox Type.* schemas in the outputs object. Prefer precise schemas. A precise schema gives a precise Static<> type for the run return and for any parent reading child.outputs, and it makes runtime validation enforce the real shape instead of accepting values without checking that precise shape. Reach for Type.Unknown(), Type.Any(), Type.Array(Type.Unknown()), or Type.Object({}, { additionalProperties: true }) only for genuinely dynamic data whose shape you cannot know ahead of time. Output schemas carry description in their options object. A declared output is required when its schema is not wrapped in Type.Optional(...); wrap outputs that may be absent in Type.Optional(...). A required output means the workflow run return object must contain that output before the run can complete; a missing required output fails with missing output "<key>", and a declared value whose runtime type does not match the schema fails with output "<key>" expected <type>, got <actual>. For child workflow calls, the parent boundary fails before the parent continues. On completion, Atomic validates declared outputs against their schemas with TypeBox Value and recursively checks every returned or exposed value for JSON serializability. During child output replay, Atomic also performs a structured-clone safety check after JSON validation so continuation can restore completed child workflow boundaries.

Prefer precise schemas

A loose output like Type.Unknown() or Type.Object({}, { additionalProperties: true }) types the run return and child.outputs.x as unknown/Record<string, unknown>, so every consumer must cast or guard before using the value, and runtime validation only checks “is this JSON?” instead of the real shape. Declaring the shape fixes both at once:
The same rule applies to inputs: inputs: { counts: Type.Array(Type.Number()) } makes ctx.inputs.counts a number[], while Type.Array(Type.Unknown()) only gives you unknown[].

Type.Unsafe<T>() escape hatch for deeply-nested values

When you already have a precise TypeScript type for a deeply-nested serializable value and don’t want to hand-write the equivalent TypeBox schema, wrap a permissive runtime schema with Type.Unsafe<MyType>(...). The static type becomes exactly MyType (so ctx.inputs, the run return, and child.outputs stay precise), while the runtime check stays as lenient as the wrapped schema. Use a type alias rather than an interface for the wrapped type — an interface has no implicit index signature, so it does not satisfy the serializable-output constraint:
Tradeoff: Type.Unsafe<T>() does not deeply validate at runtime — it trusts that the produced value matches T. Use it when the producing code already guarantees the shape (the contract-complex-leaf contract workflow does exactly this, wrapping Type.Unsafe<ComplexPacket>(...) and Type.Unsafe<readonly ComplexRecord[]>(...) around permissive runtime schemas). When you can express the shape directly, prefer a real Type.Object(...)/Type.Array(...) so runtime validation also catches drift. Keep bare Type.Unknown() and Type.Object({}, { additionalProperties: true }) for the rare cases where the value is genuinely dynamic.

How types flow

  • ctx.inputs.x is Static<inputSchema> for the input you declared as inputs: { x: schema } — required and defaulted schemas are always present, and Type.Optional(...) adds | undefined.
  • TypeScript checks the run return against your declared outputs at compile time (a missing required output or wrong value type is a TypeScript error), and TypeBox Value checks it at runtime (rejecting undeclared keys and enforcing the declared shape recursively).
  • ctx.workflow(child) returns a discriminated child result. When child.exited === false, child.outputs is the child’s full declared outputs contract; when child.exited === true, child.outputs is Partial<TOutputs> because child ctx.exit({ outputs }) may intentionally provide only a subset.
Use Static<typeof schema> (both Static and TSchema are re-exported from @bastani/workflows) when you need the inferred TypeScript type of a schema directly — for example to type a helper that builds an output value.

Stage follow-on user messages

ctx.stage() returns a StageContext with sendUserMessage(content, options?) to inject a normal follow-on user turn into that stage’s AgentSession. Use this when workflow code needs to continue an existing stage session after stage.prompt(...) has already resolved, including schema-backed stages where prompt() is intentionally one-shot because the structured-output tool may be called exactly once.
When the stage session is idle, sendUserMessage() starts the next user turn immediately and waits for that turn to finish under the normal workflow stage guard: it observes the stage concurrency limiter, workflow abort/cancellation signals, MCP scoping, readiness gates, and session metadata capture. If sendUserMessage() is the first live call on a ctx.stage(...) handle, Atomic records the stage as a normal running/completed graph node. If it is called after a prior prompt()/complete() has already completed the stage, the follow-on turn still uses internal abort/cancellation and concurrency protection while reusing the completed stage session. The content argument mirrors the Atomic SDK and accepts either a string or text/image content blocks such as [{ type: "text", text: "Describe this" }, { type: "image", data: "...", mimeType: "image/png" }] when the underlying stage session supports native user-message delivery. Non-native fallback adapters only support string content and reject text/image block arrays instead of stringifying them. Idle non-native fallback delivery sends the follow-on string to the already-selected session directly, so workflow model fallback retries are not re-run for that injected turn. When the stage is already streaming, the message is queued as a follow-up by default; pass { deliverAs: "steer" } to steer the active turn instead, or { deliverAs: "followUp" } to be explicit. deliverAs only affects streaming delivery and is a no-op for idle sessions. Follow-on turns preserve the stage’s mcp.allow / mcp.deny scope for the injected user turn, just like the original prompt(). The older stage.steer(text) and stage.followUp(text) methods are still available for queueing while a turn is active, but they do not start a new idle turn. Custom AgentSessionAdapter implementations must make asynchronous idle-turn ownership observable through their public subscribe() stream: emit { type: "agent_start" } when the submitted message has entered the turn, before waiting for that turn to finish, and emit { type: "agent_end", messages } when that turn terminates. This applies both to native sendUserMessage() implementations and to the required prompt() fallback when sendUserMessage is omitted. Atomic retains the resulting logical ownership after releasing serialized message admission, so a concurrent second message is routed as steering/follow-up rather than another prompt even when the adapter publishes isStreaming asynchronously after agent_start. Correlated turn generations prevent a late end or older delivery settlement from clearing a newer owner. A subscription may replay earlier lifecycle state synchronously during registration; an untagged synchronous replay is treated as a snapshot and does not consume a later current-turn end. If an adapter can emit a delayed end for a replayed turn while a newer turn is active, it must attach the same stable string or numeric turnId to that replayed agent_start and its matching agent_end; Atomic then correlates the old end without disturbing current ownership. After subscribe() returns, adapters must emit agent_start only for newly started turns, never as a delayed replay of an earlier turn. Adapters that enter streaming synchronously are also detected through isStreaming; the bundled Atomic session additionally retains its internal handshake for compatibility. Implementations must not delay the current turn’s agent_start until turn completion. Externally produced traffic has a separate lifecycle rule. Intercom messages and async bash/subagent completion notices received while a workflow stage generation is still open are admitted through the stage AgentSession’s native steering/follow-up queue. For a busy stage, admission into the generation boundary happens synchronously before the exact foreground subagent owner’s probe/commit detach handshake; model-visible queue insertion waits inside that admitted delivery until the handshake is claimed or falls back after an unclaimed/vanished owner. A commit accepted within a parallel foreground group releases aggregate supervision for every active sibling while retaining their process and eventual-result ownership. Reserving admission before the asynchronous handshake prevents terminal close from overtaking an in-flight Intercom delivery, while waiting inside the reservation prevents a blocking child request from queueing behind either a single foreground tool call or a parallel aggregate still waiting on another child. The stage drains already-admitted work before publishing its terminal snapshot, including schema-backed turns that have already called structured_output. Closing the generation is atomic with admission: a notification admitted first belongs to that stage, while ordinary detached notifications arriving after close cannot reopen or mutate the completed stage and are surfaced once through the main-chat notification path instead. A blocking sibling intercom.ask is the deliberate exception: when the completed stage retains a valid conversation, Atomic schedules a post-mortem turn in that conversation so it can inspect the exact ask and reply without changing terminal workflow state. Failed running-stage admission and failed post-mortem admission return correlated actionable errors to the asker instead of consuming the full reply timeout. Stage completion never waits for producers that are still running; only traffic already admitted at the close boundary is drained. Explicit sendUserMessage() calls and post-mortem stage chat remain deliberate user/workflow-authored follow-up turns on the retained session.

Early exit with ctx.exit()

Use ctx.exit(options?) when workflow code intentionally stops the current run from a helper, branch, loop, or precondition guard without classifying the run as failed. ctx.exit() throws an executor-owned control signal and is typed as never, so code after it is unreachable. In async run bodies, prefer return ctx.exit(...) when the exit is the only path so TypeScript can see the non-returning branch.
ctx.exit() accepts status: "completed" | "skipped" | "cancelled" | "blocked"; it never accepts "failed" or "killed" because thrown errors and internal destructive cancellation keep those meanings. status defaults to "completed". reason is persisted and shown in status surfaces, including the default /workflow status list and /workflow status <runId> detail, so do not put secrets in it. outputs may contain a partial subset of declared outputs; provided keys still must be declared in the workflow’s outputs object, match their TypeBox schema, and be JSON-serializable. Atomic allows missing required outputs only on the ctx.exit(...) path. Exited runs are terminal and not resumable; public pause, interrupt, and quit, plus internal destructive cancellation, keep their distinct existing behavior. The first selected ctx.exit({ outputs }) snapshots its output payload synchronously by value before JavaScript finally blocks or cleanup callbacks can mutate the caller-owned object. The snapshot preserves undeclared keys and invalid values until post-cleanup validation, so deleting an undeclared key or changing an invalid value after ctx.exit(...) does not change the terminal validation result. If reading status, reason, or outputs options, or enumerating/copying the output snapshot itself, throws, Atomic still selects the exit signal, runs workflow-exit cleanup when feasible, and then records a terminal non-resumable authoring failure (resumable: false) if no external terminal control won first. After the first ctx.exit(...) wins, the executor treats that exit as a level-triggered gate. Later delayed calls to ctx.stage, ctx.task, ctx.chain, ctx.parallel, ctx.workflow, or graph-backed ctx.ui.* prompts rethrow the selected exit signal before creating stages, prompt nodes, child runs, or control handles. Retained StageContext handles from before the exit also become inert: prompt, complete, steering/follow-up, model/thinking controls, tree navigation, compaction, abort, and attached-pane session-realization paths refuse to touch or create an AgentSession after the exit is selected. ctx.parallel stops dequeuing queued work after exit even with failFast: false and limited concurrency; already-started stages and prompt nodes are finalized as skipped with a workflow-exit reason that prompt-node abort handling preserves instead of overwriting with a generic run-aborted reason. Continuation replay also observes the exit gate. Replayed ctx.stage(...).prompt(...), replayed complete(...), graph-backed prompt-node replay, and completed child-boundary replay re-check for a selected exit after their replay microtask and before writing a current-run completed stage end. If ctx.exit(...) wins that gap, the pending replay finalizer is skipped/suppressed with the workflow-exit reason instead of creating a misleading completed stage in the resumed run. The store is the terminal authority for all run-end races. ctx.exit(...) starts cleanup before validating exit outputs, and an internal destructive cancellation can still win the terminal recordRunEnd write while that cleanup is pending. When that happens, the SDK RunResult, onRunEnd callback, live store, and persisted workflow.run.end entries all report the canonical killed state; the losing ctx.exit status or validation failure is not returned and does not append a second run-end entry. Control-signal probing is fail-closed. When the executor inspects an arbitrary thrown value or abort reason for internal workflow-exit markers, parent-exit markers, aggregate errors, cause, reason, or scope, throwing or inaccessible accessors are treated as “no signal for that branch.” The run then continues through ordinary failure finalization, or the ordinary killed path for external abort reasons, instead of letting author-defined getters escape the executor catch path or be misclassified as ctx.exit(...).

Workflow Composition

Use workflow composition when a workflow calls a reusable user-defined workflow from the project or package, or a bundled builtin workflow, and consumes its outputs as a tracked boundary stage. Import the child definition with a normal TypeScript import, then pass it directly to ctx.workflow(workflowDefinition, options). ctx.workflow(...) does not accept registry names, path objects, or string aliases. For workflows intended to be called by parent workflows, declare every field a parent should rely on in the child workflow’s outputs object, including result. No output exists without declaration: a child exposes exactly its declared outputs, and returning an undeclared key fails the child call.

Compose with a user-defined workflow

User-defined workflows are ordinary TypeScript modules. Import the workflow definition with a relative module specifier and call it directly from the parent workflow:

Compose with builtin workflows

Parent workflows can call exported builtin workflow definitions like user-defined workflows. Use the barrel export to import several builtins:
Or import one builtin from its individual module path:
Common builtin import targets: Example parent workflow that runs builtin deep research, then chooses either goal or ralph as the nested implementation runner:
Passing a workflow definition directly to ctx.workflow(...) uses the child workflow’s normalized name for replay metadata and default boundary labels (shared-research for the user-defined example above, or builtin names such as deep-research-codebase, goal, and ralph). ctx.workflow(workflowDefinition) starts a nested workflow behind a parent boundary stage named workflow:<workflow-name> by default. User-facing status and graph views flatten that child into the parent run, so composition behaves like inlining the child workflow code: child stages, HIL prompt nodes, and deeper imported workflows appear in one expanded graph. The nested run id remains available internally for routing attach/pause/interrupt/resume to the correct live stage, but it is not shown as a separate top-level /workflow status entry. The returned child result has: ctx.workflow() options: Output exposure rules:
A child exposes only outputs declared in outputs and returned from run or supplied to ctx.exit({ outputs }). There are no implicit outputs and no raw return-object passthrough. If run returns a key that was not declared in outputs, the child run fails with atomic-workflows: workflow "<childName>" returned undeclared output "<key>"; declare it in outputs or remove it from the run return, and the parent surfaces that failure through the wrapper atomic-workflows: child workflow "<childName>" (<displayName>) failed with status failed: .... A child with no declared outputs therefore exposes no outputs. Missing required outputs, schema type mismatches, and non-JSON-serializable returned values fail normal child completion before the parent continues; child ctx.exit({ outputs }) allows missing required outputs but still validates every provided key and sets child.exited === true so parent code must handle the partial shape. Pass only workflow definitions to ctx.workflow(...). Import reusable workflows with TypeScript import statements first; use /workflow names such as goal only for launching named runs, not as ctx.workflow(...) arguments. If a module is missing or does not export a workflow definition, workflow discovery fails when loading that module. Nested child workflows count against maxDepth (default 4 total workflow levels). The graph includes both the parent boundary node and the imported child workflow’s own stages while the child is loading/running, so the user can observe progress and interrupt sub-workflows before they complete. Completed boundaries still retain the child workflow name, child run id prefix, and exposed output count for replay/debugging. Skipped or failed boundaries do not retain child-edge metadata (workflowChild / workflowChildRun), and graph expansion ignores any stale non-completed boundary metadata from older persisted sessions instead of flattening an unrelated child run. Use stageName when the parent needs a more specific label, but keep it concise so the child summary remains readable in the graph. If a parent workflow exits through ctx.exit(...) while a child workflow is in flight, the parent executor only skips the parent boundary and sends the child a typed parent-exit abort reason. The hidden child executor owns child cleanup: active child stages and prompt nodes are skipped for workflow-exit, live child stage handles/sessions are disposed, and the child run is finalized as terminal cancelled (not killed) and non-resumable. The child executor writes each skipped child workflow.stage.end exactly once before its child workflow.run.end, and parent exit finalization waits for that child cleanup before writing the parent workflow.run.end, so restored sessions do not reconstruct the child as interrupted or failed. The skipped parent boundary clears any live child-run edge before store or persistence updates, so status/graph views do not display stale child stages from a boundary that did not complete. A delayed parent branch that calls ctx.workflow(...) after the exit gate is selected does not create a boundary or child run. Continuation replay treats the parent child-workflow boundary as the durable checkpoint: a previously completed child boundary replays with the original exposed outputs and without re-running the child, while a child that failed or was interrupted before completion starts again from the beginning on continuation. If ctx.exit(...) wins while a completed boundary is being replayed but before replay finalization, the boundary is finalized as skipped and its preloaded child metadata is omitted from store, persistence, restore, and expanded graph views.

The workflow() Definition

workflow(spec) is the only supported authoring API. It validates the schema maps, normalizes or infers the name, and returns a frozen branded definition that discovery and ctx.workflow(...) accept.

name

The name is optional; when you omit it, Atomic infers it from the caller filename. Lookup normalization trims and lowercases the name, changes whitespace and underscores to hyphens, removes other punctuation, collapses repeated hyphens, and trims edge hyphens.

description

Discovery and inspection surfaces show this required listing text. The compiled definition preserves it unchanged.

inputs

Each key maps to a TypeBox schema and becomes a typed member of ctx.inputs. Atomic validates inputs before the workflow body starts; see Inputs for picker behavior, defaults, and runtime rules.

outputs

The output schema map is required, including for outputless workflows where it is {}. TypeScript checks the run return against it at compile time, and Atomic checks it at runtime; see Outputs for declaration, serialization, and child-exposure rules.

worktreeFromInputs

The values name workflow inputs, not literal paths. The binding becomes the compiled definition’s inputBindings.worktree default for stages and tasks.

run(ctx)

The workflow body may be synchronous or asynchronous. Return exactly the declared output keys, or call ctx.exit(...) for an intentional terminal exit.

Compiled definition fields

workflow({...}) returns definitions that narrow outputs to required and carry an internal nominal brand. Do not construct __piWorkflow objects by hand: discovery and child composition accept only definitions minted by workflow({...}).

WorkflowContext

The run function receives ctx: WorkflowRunContext. Prefer its high-level primitives because they create tracked graph nodes and consistent handoffs.

ctx.inputs

Typed, validated input values from the definition’s inputs schema map. Atomic applies defaults before run starts.

ctx.cwd

Invocation working directory for workflow-owned artifacts. It defaults to the host process cwd when omitted.

ctx.task(name, options)

Creates one tracked stage, prompts its agent session, and returns a reusable task result. options is required and accepts prompt or its task alias plus the task and stage fields documented below.

ctx.chain(steps, options?)

Runs named task steps in sequence. The first missing task uses {task} from chain options; later missing tasks use {previous}.

ctx.parallel(steps, options?)

Runs named task steps concurrently, subject to concurrency and failFast. The call snapshots the current graph frontier at fan-out, so every branch uses the same parent set even when queued or allowed to continue after a sibling failure; downstream stages depend on all settled branches.

ctx.workflow(definition, options?)

Executes an imported workflow definition behind a tracked parent boundary. The type system requires inputs when the child has required inputs, while stageName defaults to workflow:<workflow-name>.
The method accepts only branded definitions, not names, aliases, or path objects. See Workflow Composition for graph flattening, replay, failure, and parent-exit behavior, and WorkflowChildResult for the discriminated result.

ctx.stage(name, options?)

Creates and registers a named stage synchronously; work starts when you call a method such as prompt() or complete(). Use it when ctx.task is too coarse and direct session control is required.

ctx.ui

Human-in-the-loop primitives that suspend at the callsite. They create awaiting-input graph nodes at runtime; see Lifecycle Notices and Human Input.

ctx.ui.input(prompt)

Prompts for a text value. The promise resolves with the submitted string.

ctx.ui.confirm(message)

Prompts for a boolean confirmation. The promise resolves to true or false.

ctx.ui.select(message, options)

Prompts for one string-literal option. An empty options array throws before Atomic creates a prompt node.

ctx.ui.editor(initial?)

Opens the multiline editor and resolves with its text. Pass initial to seed the editor.

ctx.ui.custom(factory, options?)

Builds a custom TUI component and resolves with the value passed to done(value). Workflow graph hosts reject overlay: true; label is display-only and defaults to "Custom TUI prompt", while replayIdentity should change when widget semantics change and must not contain secrets. See Lifecycle Notices and Human Input for replay identity, answer routing, and interactive-only constraints.

ctx.tool(name, args, fn, options?)

Runs arbitrary TypeScript code and durably caches its serializable result by call order plus the content hash of name and args. A completed call replays without rerunning fn, so use this primitive for durable side effects. Options:
  • retriesAllowed — retries failures when true; default false.
  • maxAttempts — maximum attempts when retries are enabled; default 3.
  • intervalMs — initial retry interval; default 1000.
  • backoffRate — retry interval multiplier; default 2.
See ctx.tool — durable cached tool execution for the full example and cancellation behavior.

ctx.exit(options?)

Intentionally ends the current run from any call depth. status defaults to "completed"; the runtime persists and displays reason, and outputs may provide only declared, schema-valid, serializable output keys. See Early exit with ctx.exit() for snapshotting, cleanup, replay, and race semantics.

Task and Stage Options

StageOptions and task session fields share the fields below. ctx.task, ctx.chain, and ctx.parallel inherit these options where their signatures use the corresponding option type.

prompt / task

Aliases for task text. Prefer prompt in authored workflow files because it mirrors stage.prompt(...); task remains a supported alias inside authored ctx.task, ctx.chain, and ctx.parallel calls.

previous

Use previous and {previous} only for compact handoffs. If the prompt has no placeholder, the runtime appends the context, so a large payload can silently bloat the next prompt. For large handoffs, write artifacts to files, pass their paths with reads, and tell downstream stages to read only the needed sections. Put the instruction in the downstream prompt, for example Read the file at ${artifactPath} and use only the sections needed for this stage. Prefer outputMode: "file-only" when the parent needs only the artifact path. See Compression and Artifact Handoffs and Filesystem Context for complete patterns.

context / forkFromSessionFile

Select a clean session or a forked context, with forkFromSessionFile naming an explicit fork source. Omitting context creates a fresh session unless the runtime is reopening durable state; see Locally Scoped Stage Prompts for choosing fresh reviewer context versus coherent implementation context.

group

Sets the stage session’s Intercom home group so orchestrated stages can be isolated into coordination groups: a stage in group G can only intercom peers in G. Provide a named string to join that group, or boolean true to auto-generate one shared UUID group per ctx.parallel(...) set (minted once and shared across every item in that set — never a fresh id per item), so a whole level of reviewers lands in the same isolated group. Authored workflow values accept the trimmed, case-insensitive string sentinels "true" and "auto". Those two names are reserved for automatic grouping; use a different name when you need a literal named group. Omit group to inherit per the precedence chain (ultimately "default"). group is accepted on stage/task options, on ctx.parallel(...) options, and per parallel step — a step-level group overrides the parallel options’ group. The resolved value is injected per-session (race-safe across concurrently running in-process stages, stable across model fallback). Group assignment is gated on intercom capability: a stage with noTools, a tools allowlist that omits intercom, or excludedTools containing intercom is never placed into a group (so an agent is never isolated into a group it cannot use). Subagents spawned by a grouped stage inherit that stage’s group by default (see subagents.md), so a reviewer level and its helper subagents form one isolated group. The subagent-only contact_supervisor channel still reaches the supervisor across group boundaries through a broker capability bound to the child/supervisor relationship and restored across reconnects; ordinary client send frames never gain cross-group authority from a channel flag. The builtin goal and ralph workflows use this to isolate each reviewer level into its own group (goal-reviewers-turn-N / ralph-reviewers-iter-N): same-level reviewers coordinate with each other but cannot reach the worker, orchestrator, parent chat, or other levels, which also keeps reviewer intercom chatter out of the main/parent context window. Recommended default: unless the user requests otherwise, give each workflow invocation its own intercom group. To share one group across every stage of the invocation, mint one invocation-scoped literal name inside the workflow’s run function (for example const group = "myflow-" + randomUUID(); from node:crypto) and pass it via the group option on each stage, task, or parallel step; note that group: true is only shared per ctx.parallel(...) set and mints a fresh UUID per non-parallel stage, so it isolates stages from each other rather than grouping the whole run. Ungrouped sessions all collapse into the shared "default" group, so an ungrouped workflow’s stage and subagent intercom traffic — including async subagent-result notices — can reach the parent chat and other concurrent runs. The shipped workflow prompt guidance instructs agents to isolate invocations this way by default.

model

Selects the primary stage model. String values can carry reasoning and context-window suffixes described under Reasoning levels and Context windows.

fallbackModels / fallbackThinkingLevels

fallbackModels tries the primary first, each fallback in order, and then the current Atomic-selected model when available. It advances for rate limits and quota or usage-limit exhaustion, including messages such as The usage limit has been reached and codes such as usage_limit_reached or insufficient_quota. Auth/provider outages, unavailable models, network timeouts, generic transport errors such as Connection error. or fetch failed, and 5xx responses also advance the chain. Request/context incompatibility also advances it, including HTTP 400/413/422 bad, unprocessable, or payload-too-large requests; unsupported tools or parameters; context-length or context-window overflow; and too large, invalid_request, or bad_request errors. This lets the chain reach the current selected user model when no configured candidate can serve the request. Workflow-code errors, tool failures, validation failures, refusals, content-filter or safety blocks, cancellations, and task failures do not advance the chain. A reattached finished stage starts on the model that last succeeded; if that model fails retryably, the full chain restarts from the primary.

thinkingLevel (deprecated)

Sets the default reasoning effort for candidates without a suffix. A suffix on the model string wins.

contextWindow / contextWindowStrict

Applies a stage-wide context-window token budget. The runtime rejects unsupported values when contextWindowStrict is true; otherwise, the model keeps its default.

scopedModels

Supplies stage-scoped model objects and optional compatibility reasoning levels. The nested thinkingLevel field is deprecated.

tools / noTools / excludedTools

tools is an allowlist across built-in and bundled extension tools; list every tool the stage should see. excludedTools and noTools: "all" still win. The bundled subagent tool is available by default with the same five delegated-level depth guard as main chat. Bundled subagent definitions from @bastani/subagents are available to that tool. Explicitly list tools such as subagent, web_search, fetch_content, or intercom when using an allowlist; workflow stages running inside subagent child processes retain isolated resource discovery and the nested-depth guard. Workflow stages use the same upstream-compatible bash tool as normal Atomic sessions. Enabled commands run through the configured shell with the stage process permissions. There is no command-text allow/deny option: expose or hide shell access with these tool fields, prefer narrow custom tools for repeatable operations, and use a container, VM, or other sandbox for stronger isolation.

customTools

Adds stage-local tool definitions using the Atomic tool contract. Each definition supplies its schema and execute handler.

mcp

Scopes MCP servers for one stage. The runtime applies the scope before execution and clears it after the stage settles; omitting mcp leaves server access unrestricted by workflow-stage scope.

schema

Enables a schema-specific, single-use final-answer tool for that item. ctx.stage, ctx.task, ctx.chain, and ctx.parallel items accept a TypeBox schema or a plain JSON Schema descriptor object. The schema may describe an object, array, or primitive, and the captured JSON value becomes the schema-backed stage.prompt(...) result or WorkflowTaskResult.structured; task text remains formatted JSON for handoffs. A schema-backed StageContext supports one prompt() call, so create another stage for another structured prompt. Missing or invalid structured_output calls receive up to three corrective follow-ups quoting the contract error and reminding the model to call structured_output instead of replying with plain JSON. An explicit tool allowlist automatically receives the final-answer tool, while items without schema do not.

output / outputMode

Writes stage/task output to a path or disables output persistence with false. outputMode defaults to inline; file-only keeps the parent result compact by returning an artifact reference instead of full text and requires an output path.

reads

Provides files for the stage to read before running, or disables inherited reads with false. Paths are supplied as readonly strings.

maxOutput

Limits inline output by bytes, lines, or both. Omitted bounds default to 204800 bytes and 5000 lines.

artifacts

Controls automatic session and worktree-diff artifact collection in task results and defaults to true; explicit output-file artifacts remain available when automatic collection is disabled.

worktree

Requests a runner-managed branch-backed temporary worktree for an authored ctx.task(...). Atomic creates it at <main-root>/.atomic/worktrees/<flattened-name> on branch worktree-<flattened-name>, replacing / in generated names with +. Creation remains anchored at the canonical main root when invoked inside a linked worktree. The base ref resolves as explicit baseBranch, then origin/<default-branch> (fetched when absent), then HEAD. Atomic propagates local settings, configures the main repository’s Husky or populated hooks directory through shared core.hooksPath, symlinks configured worktree.symlinkDirectories, and copies gitignored .worktreeinclude matches without overwriting tracked files. It is mutually exclusive with gitWorktreeDir; cleanup forcibly removes the worktree and deletes its branch even when startup fails before the callback.

gitWorktreeDir / baseBranch

Selects or creates a reusable same-repository Git worktree for ctx.stage, ctx.task, ctx.chain, and ctx.parallel.
  • Creation and validation: A missing path is created with git worktree add --detach <path> <baseBranch> from the canonical main repository root, where an omitted or blank baseBranch defaults to HEAD. Existing paths must be same-repository worktree roots outside the invoking checkout; the checkout itself, nested targets, and missing targets whose symlinked parent resolves inside it are rejected.
  • Cwd remapping: The default cwd preserves the invoking repository-relative subdirectory inside the worktree. Absolute cwd values inside the invoking repository are remapped, values already inside the worktree are preserved, and relative values resolve from the worktree cwd without lexical or symlink escape.
  • Output containment: Runner-managed reusable-worktree relative outputs follow the effective worktree cwd and cannot escape through traversal or symlinks. Temporary-worktree outputs are copied to distinct runner-owned artifact directories before cleanup, including in file-only mode. Explicit absolute outputs remain caller-selected.
  • Caching and diagnostics: Temporary isolation defaults to the runner invocation cwd, and relative task cwd values resolve there. Reusable setup is cached by canonical repository and target identity independently of equivalent path spelling or baseBranch, revalidates checkout identity before reuse, retries one transient timeout from read-only repository probes, and reports the exact Git command, cwd, timeout, elapsed time, exit status or signal, and spawn error details on failure.
  • Security boundary: Worktrees isolate checkouts and cwd, not the operating system. Use a container, VM, or another OS-enforced boundary for untrusted code that can race or mutate arbitrary paths.
For lower-level integrations, setupGitWorktree(options) returns the validated and remapped setup result.

sessionDir

Overrides the stage transcript directory, including for forked stages. In a headless run launched with atomic --mode json --session-dir <dir> -p '/workflow <name> ...', Atomic writes the main chat transcript and every stage transcript under <dir>; the same inheritance applies when the non-default directory comes from ATOMIC_CODING_AGENT_SESSION_DIR or settings. Without a non-default host directory, stages use Atomic’s global session store.

cwd / agentDir

Select the stage working directory and agent configuration directory. Worktree-enabled cwd values are remapped and contained by the rules above.

Host-supplied SDK seams

These are advanced host-supplied SDK seams on the runtime StageOptions used by embedded integrations, not ordinary workflow-file defaults. The standalone workflow-package authoring declaration intentionally omits most of them and types sessionManager and settingsManager as never, so package-authored workflows should not pass these fields directly. The runtime strips workflow-owned fields before forwarding session options. Internal durable fields such as resumeFromSessionFile, durableReplayKey, and durableAccumulatedDurationMs are not public authoring options.

name (step items)

Every authored chain and parallel item has a required display name.

chainDir

WorkflowChainOptions.chainDir sets the base directory for relative reads and outputs inside an authored ctx.chain(...). It is an in-workflow primitive option, not a top-level workflow tool argument.

concurrency / failFast

WorkflowParallelOptions uses concurrency to bound active tasks in an authored ctx.parallel(...). When omitted, the runtime uses the workflow’s defaultConcurrency setting, which defaults to 4; parallel execution is fail-fast unless failFast is explicitly false.

Stage prompt options (StagePromptOptions)

These options apply to stage.prompt(...), not to stage creation. They control prompt expansion, images, streaming/source metadata, preflight reporting, and per-prompt output/session behavior.

Completion options (CompleteStageOpts)

These options apply to stage.complete(...). fallbackThinkingLevels is the same deprecated compatibility helper used by stage options.

Reasoning levels

Each model and fallbackModels entry accepts a model_name:thinking_effort suffix that sets the reasoning effort for that candidate (off, minimal, low, medium, high, xhigh, max). The selected model’s capability map still governs whether xhigh or max is available. The model string includes the effort, so one fallback chain can mix efforts—for example, a high-effort primary with lower-effort, cheaper fallbacks:
The standalone thinkingLevel stage option is deprecated. It still applies as a default to any candidate without a suffix, and when both are present the suffix wins, but new workflows should fold the effort into the model strings:
This applies everywhere a stage accepts a model: direct ctx.task/ctx.chain/ctx.parallel options, ctx.stage options, builtin workflow stage definitions, and workflow parameters. fallbackThinkingLevels is an optional compatibility helper aligned by index to fallbackModels; it applies only to fallback entries that do not already carry a suffix. Each WorkflowModelAttempt reports the resolved model and the effective reasoning effort used for that attempt.

Context windows

A model/fallbackModels entry may also request a context-window budget with a parenthesized size token in the model-name portion. Place the token before or after the optional :reasoning suffix to prevent a conflict with the reasoning level. This mirrors GitHub Copilot’s Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) model-name convention:
The token accepts the same compact sizes as the --context-window flag (1m, 1.1m, 936k, 400k, or a raw token count), plus a generic (long) marker, and the runtime resolves it against that specific candidate model’s advertised windows:
  • (long) — a size-agnostic long-context marker that selects the model’s advertised long tier regardless of its exact size, so the same token works across models with different long tiers;
  • a request at or below the model’s default window keeps the default;
  • a request above the default selects the long tier — an exact supported window is used as-is, otherwise the smallest supported window at or above the request is selected, rounding up so a rounded marker like (1m) or (1.1m) lands on the long tier even when it sits slightly above or below the marker size (e.g. (1m) selects claude-opus-4.8’s 1M tier and gpt-5.5’s 1.05M tier; (1.1m) matches gpt-5.5’s rounded long-tier label);
  • when the model exposes no larger tier (or is unavailable), the runtime drops the request and the session keeps the model’s default (short) window—a non-strict, automatic fallback.
The budget applies only to the candidate that carries the token; other primary and fallback models in the same chain are unaffected. A parenthesized token that is not a valid size (for example (preview)) is left attached to the model id rather than being treated as a context window. Without the token, a tiered model pins its natural default (short) window in a workflow stage, so a persisted interactive long-context preference does not leak into workflow runs — use the (1m) token or the contextWindow stage option to opt into long context. For stage-wide selection you can instead set the contextWindow (and contextWindowStrict) stage option, which maps to the SDK createAgentSession options of the same name.

StageContext

ctx.stage(name, options?) returns direct control of a tracked stage session. The executor owns session disposal and wraps stage operations with workflow lifecycle tracking.

stage.name

Human-readable stage name for the TUI and persisted state. It is the name passed to ctx.stage(...).

stage.prompt(text, options?)

Sends a prompt and waits for completion. A schema-backed stage resolves to the schema’s static value and is one-shot; otherwise it resolves to text.

stage.complete(text, options?)

Runs the lower-level completion adapter and returns text. Completion options can select a primary model, fallback models, deprecated fallback reasoning helpers, and maxTokens.

stage.sendUserMessage(content, options?)

Sends a normal follow-on user turn to the retained stage session. This method starts a turn immediately when the session is idle; while streaming, it queues a follow-up by default or sends steering when deliverAs: "steer". Native sessions accept strings or text/image content blocks. Non-native fallback adapters accept only strings and reject block arrays; deliverAs affects streaming delivery only, and follow-on turns retain the stage MCP scope. Externally produced Intercom and async bash/subagent notices admitted before the generation closes drain through the same session. When a busy stage owns a foreground subagent, exact-owner detach gets first refusal before Intercom enters this boundary; unclaimed traffic then uses normal stage admission. Traffic arriving after the atomic close boundary cannot reopen the completed stage and is surfaced once through the main-chat path instead. See Stage follow-on user messages for the full lifecycle and schema-backed example.

stage.steer(text) / stage.followUp(text)

Queues text while a turn is active. These methods do not start a new idle turn; use sendUserMessage() to start one.

stage.subscribe(listener)

Subscribes to stage-session events and returns an unsubscribe function. The lean standalone authoring declaration intentionally leaves the event payload opaque; Atomic’s embedded runtime surface specializes it to AgentSessionEvent. Call the returned function to stop receiving events.

stage.sessionId / stage.sessionFile

Expose the retained session identifier and its optional transcript file. sessionFile is undefined when no file is available.

stage.setModel(model) / stage.setThinkingLevel(level) / stage.cycleModel() / stage.cycleThinkingLevel()

These are the externally shipped standalone authoring signatures. WorkflowModelValue accepts a string or supported SDK model object, and WorkflowThinkingLevel is "off" | "minimal" | "low" | "medium" | "high" | "xhigh" | "max"; Atomic’s embedded runtime narrows the model arguments and cycle result to its AgentSession types.

stage.agent / stage.model / stage.thinkingLevel / stage.messages / stage.isStreaming

These members provide read-only access to the current stage-session state. The standalone authoring declaration keeps SDK-owned objects opaque, while Atomic’s embedded runtime specializes these members to the corresponding AgentSession properties.

stage.navigateTree(targetId, options?)

Navigates within the current session file. The result reports cancellation and may include restored editor text.

stage.compact() / stage.abortCompaction()

Starts compaction for the stage session or aborts an active compaction. The standalone authoring declaration keeps the result opaque; Atomic’s embedded runtime specializes it to VerbatimCompactionResult.

stage.abort()

Aborts the stage session’s current operation. The returned promise settles after the runtime processes the abort request.

Result Types

Workflow primitives return serializable result contracts that carry text, structured values, artifacts, model attempts, child boundaries, and run snapshots. The root authoring declaration directly exports WorkflowTaskResult, WorkflowChildResult, WorkflowArtifact, WorkflowDetails, RunResult, and StageSnapshot; supporting conditional or union-branch aliases shown below describe the source contract but are not all separately exported by the lean standalone declaration.

WorkflowTaskResult

ctx.task returns this type; ctx.chain and ctx.parallel return arrays of it. structured is present when the item used schema.

WorkflowDetails

Used by workflow tool result rendering and Intercom integration for named, inspection, and control results.

WorkflowChildResult

Normal completion exposes the full declared output contract. A child that used ctx.exit(...), including status: "completed", exposes only a partial contract and optional exit reason; failed or internally cancelled children reject the parent call instead.

WorkflowStageResult

A schema-backed stage.prompt() resolves to the schema’s static value. A stage without schema resolves to text.

WorkflowArtifact

Describes a persisted output, session, diff, or patch and its optional task, branch, and diff statistics. path and kind are always present.

RunResult

Programmatic run(...) returns this type. exited identifies ctx.exit(...) termination, and stages contains the final stage snapshots.

Running Workflows

List or inspect unfamiliar workflows before running them. If required inputs are missing and cannot be inferred, ask for the missing values before launch:
The workflow tool action surface is:
  • discovery: list, get, inputs, plus models for the configured model catalog
  • execution: named run with validated workflow and inputs
  • inspection: status, stages, stage, transcript
  • messaging and run control: send, pause, interrupt, quit, resume
  • rediscovery: reload
From interactive chat, named workflow launches run in the background so the parent chat stays available. Run /workflow connect <run> to see agents working and chat with and steer each stage. Inspection and control calls (status, stages, stage, transcript, send, pause, resume, interrupt, quit) remain available while work runs. workflow({ action: "models" }) returns the registry’s configured-auth catalog snapshot in registry order. Each entry includes provider, id, fullId, an isCurrent marker, and availableThinkingLevels derived from the real model’s reasoning and thinkingLevelMap metadata. This is not proof of credentials, entitlements, OAuth freshness, or live provider access, and it exposes no authentication details. Named launches wait only for startup admission, not for workflow completion. Atomic returns status: "running" after durable registration, reusable-worktree setup, and other pre-body setup succeed, while the workflow body and stages continue in the background. If setup fails before the workflow body is admitted — for example, git_worktree_dir points inside the invoking checkout — the original workflow tool call instead returns a structured status: "failed" result with the allocated run id and concrete setup error. No background-start claim or orphan run is retained, so the caller can correct the inputs and retry immediately. Failures after admission remain ordinary background lifecycle outcomes reported through status and lifecycle notices. A model may launch in the foreground only when the user explicitly requests it or foreground execution is technically required, and it must tell the user before launching. Run a named workflow with inputs:
Slash equivalent:

Running a Workflow Command

Input overrides are bare key=value tokens. Atomic parses values as JSON when possible, so count=3, flag=true, and prompt="multi word value" preserve useful types. A whole input object can also be passed as one JSON token. Runtime validation is strict: unknown input keys, missing required values, type mismatches, and invalid select choices fail before a named workflow run starts or before a child workflow starts. In the TUI, /workflow <name> opens an inline input picker when the workflow declares inputs and either no arguments were supplied or required inputs are missing. Supplied values seed the picker. The picker is mounted and focused in the terminal host in both isolated and non-isolated interactive modes, so Tab/Shift+Tab, arrows, text editing, configured keybindings, Enter, Escape, and Ctrl+C remain responsive without per-keypress host⇄engine traffic. Escape or Ctrl+C cancels without starting the workflow. Pass --no-picker to skip that interactive flow. In non-interactive (-p, --print, or --mode json) sessions, named workflow dispatch waits for the terminal run snapshot and skips pickers. Because human input is runtime-only and workflows no longer carry a declaration-time HIL marker, headless dispatch does not reject a workflow because its source contains ctx.ui.*. If you copy a HIL workflow example into a headless session, it can pass dispatch and then fail when execution reaches the prompt with an error such as atomic-workflows: interactive ctx.ui.confirm is unavailable in headless (non-interactive) mode; run the workflow in interactive mode or remove the interactive prompt from this stage (the primitive name varies, including ctx.ui.custom). Run those workflows interactively, or guard/remove runtime ctx.ui.* calls before using headless mode.

Workflow Input Picker

Workflow Commands

Common controls:
Surface behavior:
  • Graph vs. stage chat - Use connect for the workflow graph. Use attach when you want a chat pane for a specific stage.
  • Hierarchy chord - ctrl+x is the workflow hierarchy chord: in an attached stage chat it means return to graph, and in the graph it means return to main chat. The workflow surface handles ctrl+x before configurable editor or tool actions, including while a composer draft, primitive prompt, custom question, stage switcher, or legacy prompt card owns input.
  • Draft preservation - Leaving a stage preserves unsent composer and prompt drafts and keeps pending custom questions unresolved so they reappear when you attach again.
  • Reserved keys - ctrl+d and q do not navigate workflow surfaces; ctrl+d keeps its ordinary editor or prompt behavior where applicable, and q remains printable in text-owning prompts. Existing esc, ctrl+c, and graph h close/hide controls are unchanged.
  • Wheel and trackpad - While the workflow graph is active, vertical wheel/trackpad gestures pan it up and down, and horizontal gestures pan wide graphs left and right when the terminal exposes horizontal wheel events; these gestures remain scoped to the graph instead of leaking into the main chat or terminal scrollback. Attached stage chats capture mouse/trackpad wheel events by default so scrolling stays inside the active stage transcript or prompt instead of falling through to terminal/main-chat scrollback.
  • Tool and node detail - Attached stage chats match main chat’s tool-detail expansion behavior while keeping expansion state local to the workflow UI context. Press Ctrl+O (the configurable app.tools.expand binding) to expand every visible workflow node and tool card, including single, parallel, and chain subagent progress, current tool activity, and artifact paths; press it again to collapse them. The toggle works for active, completed, and archived stage views, including at the supported 40-column terminal minimum. A mounted prompt, custom question, or other input-owning overlay keeps the key instead of changing expansion.
  • Async statusline - If an async/background subagent is running while the fullscreen workflow graph is open, the graph statusline mirrors the async summary so the background run remains visible; hide the graph with h, leave it with ctrl+x, or reconnect later to return to the full below-editor async widget.
  • Copy mode - Press ctrl+t inside an attached stage chat to toggle copy mode: copy mode disables workflow-chat mouse reporting so normal terminal/tmux text selection can work; press ctrl+t again to leave copy mode and restore transcript or prompt scrolling. Archived read-only stage transcripts expose the same footer and copy-mode status, so their text can also be selected and copied; esc closes the transcript and ctrl+x returns to the graph. While copy mode is on, wheel/trackpad gestures are handled by the terminal/tmux and may scroll terminal scrollback, so leave copy mode before using the wheel again.
  • Run control - Use interrupt, pause, and resume for resumable live work; resume on a non-paused run reopens the saved snapshot or overlay. Use quit to pause a live run gracefully while preserving it for /workflow resume.
  • Rediscovery - Use /workflow reload after adding, editing, installing, or removing workflow resources or package manifest workflow entries and you want Atomic to rediscover them in-process (Reloading workflow resources).
  • Status listing - /workflow status lists all retained active and terminal top-level runs by default; implementation-owned nested child runs are flattened into their parent workflow rather than listed separately. /workflow status --all is retained as a compatibility alias.
/workflows is the retained-run history alias for /workflow resume: with no id it opens the same mixed resumable/completed picker, and with an id it resumes unfinished work or opens completed inspection. It is intentionally different from /workflow list, which lists installed workflow definitions. See /workflow resume — cross-session resume selector for the full picker semantics. At the supported 40-column terminal minimum, attached stage chats use the compact ctrl+x graph · ctrl+t … footer. The TUI may truncate provider/model context to make room, but it keeps that context separate from the hierarchy hint so the controls stay readable.

Workflow Graph Viewer

Human-in-the-loop prompts appear as awaiting-input nodes in the workflow graph, not as ordinary chat modals — see Lifecycle Notices and Human Input for how to find and answer them.

Monitor and Control Runs

The workflow tool exposes lifecycle controls for non-interactive use:
Control behavior:
  • runId accepts full run ids or unique prefixes for every lifecycle and inspection action, including status. The abbreviated IDs printed by status surfaces are valid inputs. Exact IDs take precedence; a prefix shared by multiple runs returns an ambiguity diagnostic with longer matching prefixes instead of selecting the first run. Status lists and run pickers show top-level user-launched workflows; nested child runs are implementation details of the expanded parent graph.
  • status without runId lists every top-level run in the session with a concise per-run summary: run id plus abbreviated prefix, workflow name, run status, started/ended timing with pause-adjusted elapsed time, currently active stages, and awaiting-input details (count plus the stage, prompt id, kind, and message for each pending human prompt). In-flight runs are listed first. The summaries carry the exact identifiers that pause/resume/interrupt/quit/send accept, so an orchestrating agent can list runs and act on them directly.
  • statusFilter narrows the status run listing: run statuses (pending, running, paused, blocked, completed, failed, skipped, cancelled, killed) match runs directly, awaiting_input selects runs with at least one stage awaiting input or pending human prompt, and all (the default) includes everything.
  • format: "json" on data-bearing inspection actions (status, stages, stage, transcript) returns the full structured result; the default text output for status is the concise per-run summary list.
  • status / status <runId> show terminal ctx.exit(...) statuses (completed, skipped, cancelled, or blocked) and the optional exit reason when one was supplied.
  • stages lists stage summaries, including flattened stages from nested ctx.workflow(...) imports and sessionFile/transcriptPath when a stage has a persisted session. Use statusFilter: "all" to include completed, failed, skipped, and pending stages.
  • stage returns details for one stage by stage id, unique prefix, or stage name, including nested child stages shown in the expanded graph and the persisted sessionFile when available. Abbreviated stage IDs printed in graph/control messages use this same unique-prefix resolver; collisions return an ambiguity diagnostic rather than selecting a stage.
  • transcript is reference-first with a small preview by default: it returns metadata, transcript paths, and up to 5 recent entries. For targeted lookup, quote the exact sessionFile/transcriptPath value without changing platform separators (preserve Windows backslashes), search it with rg or grep, then read only small surrounding ranges. Text results include JSON-escaped sessionFileJson/transcriptPathJson lines for copy-safe path literals. Pass explicit tail or limit to override the 5-entry preview; tail overrides limit; includeToolOutput includes captured snapshot tool output in snapshot transcript results.
  • send delivery modes are auto, answer, prompt, steer, followUp, and resume.
    • Prompt answers can include promptId and can carry answer content in response, text, or message; structured UI prompts usually prefer response.
    • For a live idle stage, prompt, followUp, and eligible auto delivery all start a fresh prompt immediately; an actively streaming followUp remains queued and steer remains steering, so neither starts a concurrent prompt. The result’s delivery and message describe the action actually taken (prompt, followUp, steer, answer, or resume), not merely the requested mode. Explicit resume against a stage that is not paused is a truthful no-op, and explicit message deliveries cannot bypass a paused stage; resume it first.
    • Follow-up messaging to completed or failed stages reuses the retained sessionFile when available so the conversation resumes from the archived stage transcript instead of starting empty. If no session metadata was retained, Atomic refuses the follow-up rather than silently resetting.
    • Explicit delivery: "resume" or delivery: "steer" against a completed post-mortem stage returns a structured noop with guidance to use followUp or prompt; it never appends the supplied text or mutates workflow execution.
    • Arbitrary ctx.ui.custom<T> widget prompts require the interactive workflow graph and return a clear unsupported message when targeted through send.
  • delivery: "auto" first answers a pending prompt, then resumes paused work, then steers a streaming stage, and finally starts a fresh prompt when the live stage is idle.
  • pause, interrupt, and quit can target one top-level run or all: true; stageId cannot be combined with all: true. Stage-scoped pause and interrupt controls can target a visible nested child stage from the expanded graph; quit remains run-level. Atomic routes stage controls to the owning nested run internally.
  • interrupt is resumable: it pauses live work when pausable stages exist and keeps the run in live history/status.
  • pause is useful for pausing a live run or a single live stage without treating it as a destructive abort.
  • resume can target a stage with stageId; the target may be a stage id, unique prefix, or stage name. message is forwarded to paused work. For a live interrupted streaming prompt, Atomic preserves the existing prompt loop without duplicating the user message and injects Continue where you left off. If you believe you are finished with your original task (or a redefined task if the user told you), stop. when required before normal readiness-gate completion. For a paused stage that was idle waiting for a new stage-chat turn, a non-empty message resumes the stage and starts exactly one fresh prompt containing that message; an empty resume releases the pause without creating a prompt.
  • An explicit workflow-tool resume target that is absent from the current session store triggers targeted DBOS discovery before Atomic returns Run not found. Eligible exact IDs and unique prefixes resume under the original workflow ID; durable prefix collisions return every matching ID. Resource-loading and durable-backend failures remain visible. Ordinary workflow-tool status listing stays session-local and does not eagerly hydrate durable history.
  • quit gracefully pauses in-flight work, marks the run resumable, and leaves it available to /workflow resume.
  • reload refreshes discovered workflow resources in-process; the optional reason is echoed in the result.
Use slash commands for graph connect and stage attach because those are interactive TUI surfaces. When a run needs user input or attention, tell the user instead of polling silently.

Pausing, quitting, and resuming

Graceful quit is idempotent for an already-paused resumable run. If a run is waiting on ctx.ui, quit preserves its current DBOS prompt reservation. Answers cannot advance paused workflow code until explicit resume; checkpointing the answer releases exactly that reservation generation. Concurrent and nested prompts use composed scopes and independent DBOS reservation tokens. When a paused stage interrupted an active model turn, Atomic preserves that turn’s existing pause loop: a non-empty resume message is delivered exactly once through the resumed loop, and (if the stage has not finalized) Atomic injects Continue where you left off. If you believe you are finished with your original task (or a redefined task if the user told you), stop. before normal completion/readiness handling. A no-message interrupted-turn resume injects the same continuation directly. A different state applies when the stage was idle and waiting for a new stage-chat turn: resuming with a non-empty message starts exactly one fresh prompt containing the text, while an empty resume only releases the pause and does not fabricate a user turn or continuation. The same continuation applies to user messages queued into a live streaming stage. Steering a turn (Enter in an attached stage chat), queueing a follow-up (Ctrl+F), or using workflow({ action: "send" }) with steer/followUp delivery arms the identical continuation prompt, which Atomic injects once when the interrupted turn ends — even if several messages were queued during that turn — so a steered stage returns to its original (or user-redefined) objective instead of stopping after answering the queued message. Messages delivered to an idle stage start a fresh user turn immediately and receive no continuation nudge; abort, kill, workflow exit, and finalized/fail-fast stage boundaries suppress late prompt creation and continuation injection. When several paused stages resume together, Atomic settles every acknowledgement and then re-reads the actual stage/control state. A late rejection after its stage visibly starts counts as resumed and is not retried; genuinely paused failures remain available for a later resume. The run and durable root follow visible running work, while slash/tool output reports acknowledgement or durable-transition failures as partial progress instead of a no-op. If local resume succeeds but persisting the durable running transition fails, a later resume request retries reconciliation while the durable handle remains paused. A terminal run cannot be revived by a late acknowledgement.

Post-mortem chat vs. execution resume

These are distinct operations. Resuming workflow execution (/workflow resume) is for paused, interrupted, recoverably failed, or unfinished durable work; it may replay checkpoints, continue an incomplete stage, and dispatch remaining DAG work. Opening a post-mortem chat reopens one terminal agent stage’s retained conversation for follow-up only — it never resumes, retries, rewinds, or otherwise changes workflow execution. Any eligible terminal agent stage with a valid retained session opens as an interactive post-mortem chat regardless of how you reach it: same-process ctx.task/ctx.chain/ctx.parallel stages, completed-workflow inspection, generic /workflow attach / /workflow connect, restored/replayed durable snapshots after a restart, and workflow({ action: "send" }). Explicit /workflow attach <root-run> <nested-stage> targets are resolved through the expanded graph and routed to the child run that owns the stage while the overlay remains rooted on the requested graph; the resolved owner is preserved when sibling child workflows reuse the same local stage ID. When a nested stage is reopened after a restart or from another checkout, its session cwd comes from the durable root workflow (resolved workflow cwd first, then original invocation cwd) while stage-control ownership remains with the actual child run. Follow-up turns are appended in place to the stage’s retained session (no separate fork), so the agent may still invoke its ordinary tools and cause side effects; only the workflow DAG, run/stage status, results, timings, checkpoints, and topology are immutable. Every host session replacement or shutdown invalidates post-mortem handles, including a session whose lazy reopen is still pending: if creation finishes after the boundary, Atomic disposes the newly created session and rejects the already-submitted prompt before it can execute. A stage stays a read-only transcript when it has no valid retained agent session — prompt/HIL and boundary/summary nodes, skipped nodes without a completed conversation, non-terminal handle-less stages (another process may still own the session), and missing/malformed/deleted session files. When a known stage cannot be reopened, the attached chat shows the complete SESSION UNAVAILABLE explanation down to the supported 40-column minimum instead of incorrectly labeling an invalid file as an archived transcript. Recoverably failed stages keep their execution-resume semantics and are not silently reopened as post-mortem chat. Completed stages also remain addressable by blocking intercom.ask calls from sibling workflow stages. If an ask reaches a completed target with a retained conversation, Atomic schedules one serialized post-mortem turn in that exact conversation; no manual workflow send follow-up is needed. The target sees the original ask, and its normal intercom.reply remains correlated to the originating child session and message ID. The parent chat or another session cannot satisfy the waiter. Late-message routing uses single-owner claiming: after the workflow post-mortem router claims a completed-stage ask and assigns its completion promise, later listeners preserve that claim, making bundled extension registration order irrelevant. This reopens only the conversation. The workflow DAG and terminal stage snapshot remain completed and are never resumed or re-dispatched. If the target run or stage was deleted, lacks a valid retained conversation, is non-resumable, or fails to reopen, the caller receives a bounded actionable intercom.ask tool error instead of waiting indefinitely. Workflow stage sessions and first-party subagent transcripts created inside them are classified as internal at creation and excluded from the standard /resume, atomic -r, --continue, and global history surfaces. Fork-context stages and subagents inherit the owning run/stage marker in their initial JSONL header, avoiding a briefly visible ordinary session. They remain resumable and inspectable through the workflow-specific commands and tool actions shown here (/workflow resume, /workflow attach, workflow({ action: "status" | "stages" | "stage" | "resume" })), which read the run/stage store and its sessionFile links directly. Passing a stage session’s file path to --session still opens it explicitly. Classification requires exact internal: true plus complete run/stage metadata; malformed legacy markers and ordinary user forks remain in standard history. Legacy workflow sessions created before this marker behavior lack provable ownership and continue to appear until they age out.

Lifecycle Notices and Human Input

Atomic emits deduplicated main-chat notices when top-level workflow runs complete, fail, end blocked, or stop at an active recoverable provider/auth/rate-limit block. A recoverable block remains resumable (status surfaces and headless results report it as blocked even though the stored live snapshot stays active), is retained durably as blocked for cross-session resume, appears in the resume picker, and its notice says the workflow is blocked rather than implying terminal completion. Each blocked occurrence is deduped by its blockedAt timestamp, so a resumed workflow that hits another recoverable block re-notifies the invoking chat. Nested child workflow outcomes are reflected inside the expanded parent graph instead of producing separate top-level cards. Lifecycle notices are delivered through the coding-agent’s native idle-prompt admission when the parent chat is idle, or persisted directly to the transcript when the parent chat is streaming, so a cleared steer queue or aborted turn cannot silently drop the card. Delivery is acknowledged before dedupe is committed: while the invoking chat remains active, a rejected admission retains its original payload and retries with capped backoff even if the run changes state or notification configuration is reinstalled. Session replacement cancels those attempts and clears their payloads rather than waking an unrelated chat with an uninspectable old run. Awaiting-input workflow states are tracked for dedupe/restore, but they do not enqueue main-chat connect cards or wake the model; prompt state remains visible through workflow status/connect surfaces. When an active recoverable block is resumed in-process, Atomic dispatches a fresh-ID continuation that replays the source’s completed stages and re-runs the failed one. The durable source is left untouched (stays blocked/resumable) so it remains discoverable and recoverable — including a zero-checkpoint first-stage block — if the process dies before the continuation settles; the local source snapshot is killed so the same session will not re-resume it. A process-local claim prevents a concurrent same-session double-dispatch. Configure lifecycle behavior with workflowNotifications.enabled (default true) and workflowNotifications.notifyOn (default ["completed", "failed", "blocked", "awaiting_input"]). Human input is runtime-only: call ctx.ui.input, ctx.ui.confirm, ctx.ui.select, ctx.ui.editor, or ctx.ui.custom<T> when the workflow needs a decision. No builder-level declaration is required or supported. Human-in-the-loop prompts from ctx.ui.input, ctx.ui.confirm, ctx.ui.select, ctx.ui.editor, and ctx.ui.custom<T> appear as awaiting-input nodes in the workflow UI/graph viewer, not as ordinary chat modals. Workflow definitions do not declare HIL; runtime ctx.ui.* calls create prompt nodes. If the prompt lives inside an imported child workflow, it still appears in the same expanded parent graph so the user can focus and answer it without switching to a separate child status entry. Use /workflow connect <run-id> (or F2), then press Enter on the focused node or click a graph node to focus and open or attach it for local answers. Custom widget prompts mount inside the attached stage chat and must be completed interactively with the widget’s done(value) callback. When a workflow needs human input, answer in the graph viewer or attached stage chat when possible:
Agents can answer primitive and structured pending prompts programmatically with workflow({ action: "send", delivery: "answer", ... }); use promptId when it is present in the stage details, and provide answer content with response, text, or message. Arbitrary custom TUI widget prompts intentionally refuse this path in iteration 1 because a generic T cannot be reconstructed safely from a non-TUI payload. ctx.ui.custom<T>(factory, options?) reuses Atomic’s TUI component path: the factory receives the same real (tui, theme, keybindings, done) types as extension ctx.ui.custom, and the workflow resumes with the value passed to done(value). Use options.label for a safe display-only graph/status label and options.replayIdentity when widget semantics can change without the callsite changing. Do not put secrets in labels or replay identities; only a hash of the identity is stored, and label text is not part of replay identity. Inline connected rendering is supported; overlay: true is rejected clearly because nested workflow graph overlays are not safely supported yet. Prompt answers are replayable only while the source run remains in the live in-memory store. StageSnapshot.promptAnswerState is snapshot-safe metadata for continuation: available means a matching live answer can be replayed, unavailable means the matching prompt node exists but its private answer was purged, and ambiguous means multiple matching prompt nodes exist so Atomic asks again. The raw answer lives in a private PromptAnswerRecord ledger, is never written to snapshots or persistence, and remains resident in memory until the answer is cleared, the run is removed, or the store is cleared. Prompt replay keys include the prompt kind, message text, select choices, input/editor initial value, custom prompt identity hash, and hashed author callsite, so changing any of those inputs may intentionally re-ask on continuation. An empty ctx.ui.select(..., []) has no answerable choices and throws before creating a prompt node. Arbitrary custom-widget answers cannot be supplied through workflow send; focus the custom awaiting-input node in the interactive graph instead. If the user answers a human-in-the-loop prompt in the workflow UI or stage UI broker, the stage receives the answer directly and the active main chat receives a display-only notice (triggerTurn: false, excludeFromContext: true) containing a concise answer summary. The notice is rendered for the user and persisted for audit, but it does not wake the model, enter LLM context, or authorize answering any other workflow prompt. Prompt answers sent by the main-chat workflow tool are suppressed from this notice because the tool result already informs the current turn. When an interactive, non-schema workflow stage calls ask_user_question, Atomic waits for the stage’s assistant turn to finish and then brokers the deterministic readiness question “Are you ready to move on to the next stage?”. This includes typed or freeform questionnaire answers reported as details.answers[].kind === "chat": the assistant first gives its normal conversational response, then the stage becomes awaiting_input with inputRequest.kind: "readiness_gate" in workflow status and graph surfaces. In this chat-answer flow, choosing the ready option completes the stage and releases dependent stages. Choosing the not-ready option keeps the stage open for a genuine stage-chat turn and brokers readiness again after that turn. A chat answer is never treated as an invisible stay decision. The readiness prompt can be answered in the attached stage UI or with workflow({ action: "send", delivery: "answer", ... }). Ordinary structured-option answers retain their existing readiness behavior. A schema-backed stage that has successfully finalized through structured_output is terminal and does not reopen this readiness gate.

Durable Workflows and Cross-Session Resume

Atomic workflows use DBOS/Postgres as their sole persistent workflow backend. Atomic configures and launches DBOS lazily on the first workflow action, reuses that process-wide instance, and awaits readiness before workflow execution, resume, inspection, or deletion can access durable state. DBOS_SYSTEM_DATABASE_URL may select an existing database; DBOS query and write failures fail the workflow action and never select another backend. Zero-configuration local database. Without DBOS_SYSTEM_DATABASE_URL, Atomic runs DBOS against its own embedded Postgres built from npm-distributed binaries — no Docker daemon or system Postgres install. The cluster lives under ~/.atomic/postgres/v18 on dedicated port 5439; the first workflow action initializes it once and starts it with pg_ctl as a detached daemon that survives Atomic exiting, is shared by every concurrent Atomic session, and is never stopped by Atomic. Running as root (Linux). PostgreSQL refuses to run as UID 0, so a root Atomic process (containers, CI sandboxes, eval harnesses) resolves an unprivileged system account (postgres, nobody, or daemon), keeps the cluster under /var/lib/atomic-postgres instead (a root home directory is untraversable for that account), and runs every Postgres command with dropped privileges. When the embedded binaries themselves sit under an untraversable prefix (for example a root-owned ~/.nvm global install), Atomic copies the Postgres runtime into the cluster directory once and reuses it. When the embedded binaries are unavailable for the platform, Atomic falls back to DBOS’s reusable dbos-db Docker container. If no durable backend can be provisioned at all, workflows degrade to a process-local in-memory backend with a loud warning instead of refusing to run: the run executes normally, but its state does not survive the process and /workflow resume after exit has nothing to restore. Set DBOS_SYSTEM_DATABASE_URL to an existing Postgres to restore durability. Multiple concurrent Atomic sessions. Every Atomic process launches DBOS with a unique executor id, and running root workflows carry owner/heartbeat metadata refreshed by ordinary ≤30-second stage-timing checkpoints. Running workflows are never resume targets: a running row with a fresh heartbeat is hidden from every session’s picker and refused by direct /workflow resume <id> — resuming a workflow that is executing elsewhere would double-dispatch it. Once the heartbeat goes stale (about two minutes after a crash), the workflow surfaces as a red crashed row. When two sessions race to resume the same paused workflow, a durable first-writer-wins claim decides exactly one winner; the loser reconciles to the authoritative state and reports that the workflow changed while resume was pending.

How it works

  • Only ctx.* blocks are checkpointed: code outside ctx.* is not durable.
  • Durable side effects: Atomic flushes ctx.tool and ctx.ui writes before exposing completed results, so resume does not repeat an already-completed effect.
  • Durable graph operations: stage, task, chain, parallel, and child-workflow checkpoints include source-stage lineage plus owning-run/boundary metadata, timing, model, output, and retained chat-session references. Fresh-process resume and completed inspection reconstruct nested child runs and parallel DAG edges directly from DBOS.
  • DBOS-only discovery: /workflow resume, /workflows, completed inspection, deletion, and targeted lookup hydrate/query DBOS. Session JSONL remains only a chat transcript referenced by a current checkpoint; it is not a workflow catalog or discovery source.
  • Current format only: Atomic encodes and decodes one current DBOS format. Prior local files and older DBOS records are not read, converted, or cleaned up. Unsupported or malformed records are ignored as foreign data.
  • Child side-effect scoping: nested workflow effects are checkpointed under the durable root with stable child scopes.
  • Cross-session safety: per-process executor identity, owner/heartbeat liveness on running handles, and claim-guarded status transitions prevent double dispatch when several Atomic sessions share the database.
Privacy and retention. DBOS persists workflow inputs, completed tool outputs, UI responses, stage outputs, and chat-session paths. Treat the configured database as sensitive. History does not automatically delete records by age or count; confirmed picker deletion removes inactive DBOS workflow state while preserving independent chat transcripts. Resume after editing a workflow. Replay identity combines the workflow id with stable content hashes and call order. Editing, inserting, or reordering ctx.* calls can intentionally invalidate matches. Finish or delete retained runs before deploying incompatible workflow changes. Durable /workflow resume preserves completed stage metadata, active-stage elapsed time, total run elapsed time, and graph topology. While an LM stage or task is active, repeated durable checkpoints refresh its accumulated pause-adjusted duration even when its session file does not change, and refresh the run’s total accumulated elapsed time alongside it. Graceful quit forces an exact stage and run timing checkpoint even inside the ordinary 30-second update bucket; normal completion also persists the final accumulated run total. Each new Atomic process that reopens unfinished work starts from the latest saved baseline, so repeated process-boundary resumes keep status, graph, and lifecycle duration cumulative without double-counting pauses. A stage paused at ten seconds resumes at ten seconds, and the main-chat dashboard reports prior-session elapsed plus current-session elapsed. Completed inspection uses that same accumulated run timing rather than DBOS record wall-clock age. Replayed ctx.stage, ctx.task, ctx.chain, ctx.parallel, and child-workflow checkpoints keep their original summaries, timing, session/model metadata, nested owning-run boundaries, and parallel fanout parentage instead of appearing as freshly flattened replay nodes. If a project-local workflow created and reloaded during a chat is absent from a fresh process’s registry, resume rediscovers it from the persisted original invocation directory.

ctx.tool — durable cached tool execution

The ctx.tool(name, args, fn, options?) primitive runs arbitrary TypeScript code and caches the result durably. On resume, if that ordinal tool call already completed (matched by call order plus content hash of name + args), the runtime returns the cached result without re-executing the function — ensuring completed side effects are not repeated while still allowing two intentional same-name/same-args calls in one workflow.

/workflow resume — cross-session resume selector

The /workflow resume command mirrors /resume ergonomics and /workflows is its alias. With no id, it builds one newest-first picker from eligible live runs and current DBOS resumable/completed records. DBOS is the authoritative catalog; selected records are hydrated and revalidated before resume or inspection. Running workflows never appear: fresh-heartbeat rows are excluded in every session to prevent double dispatch, and stale ones surface as crashed. Rows carry semantic colors — completed green, paused yellow, failed/blocked/crashed red — and show checkpoint progress without the redundant pending-prompt count. The open picker live-updates on local run changes plus a bounded cross-session poll, so state transitions appear (and freshly running workflows disappear) without reopening it. Ctrl+D deletes a highlighted inactive durable or completed row after confirmation. Deletion rechecks same-process activity and the authoritative DBOS status, refuses a running workflow, and leaves host and stage chat transcripts untouched. The history surface matches /resume retention semantics: eligible runs remain searchable regardless of age or count, with no automatic history garbage collection. The picker mounts before asynchronous catalog hydration completes and merges DBOS rows when ready. Only current-format DBOS records are selectable. Atomic hides unsupported or malformed records without reinterpreting them. Selecting a paused, failed, blocked, or crash-recovery target follows the existing resume path unchanged: Atomic re-dispatches the workflow with its cached inputs and the original workflow id, so previously completed ctx.tool, ctx.ui, stage/task/chain/parallel items, and child workflow boundaries replay from durable checkpoints rather than executing again. Selecting a completed target follows a separate open path. Atomic reconstructs completed root and nested child-run snapshots from authoritative checkpoints, remaps persisted source-stage and boundary references to reconstructed stage ids, and opens the full expanded hierarchy without calling the durable resume dispatcher or re-running workflow stages, tools, tasks, prompts, or workflow code. Completed detail state is read-only. A retained stage chat may be reopened for follow-up without resuming workflow execution or mutating its DBOS handle. Current checkpoints always include supported topology; foreign checkpoints are excluded rather than displayed with inferred edges.
Explicit full IDs take precedence, while prefixes resolve across top-level live, resumable durable, and completed targets as one namespace. An exact loadable paused top-level live target resumes directly from in-session state without enumerating the durable completed-history catalog; this keeps explicit live resume responsive even when retained durable history is large and preserves live-over-durable precedence for duplicate IDs. Nested child runs remain excluded from this top-level target namespace even when addressed by an exact ID. The non-interactive workflow({ action: "resume", runId: "<id-or-prefix>" }) surface uses the same durable resumable-target lookup behavior for explicit targets. If the target is absent locally, Atomic loads workflow resources, queries the authoritative DBOS resumable catalog, and only then reports a missing run. This targeted hydration does not change workflow({ action: "status" }): an empty session-local status before explicit resume does not imply that DBOS deleted the workflow. Prefixes and other targets continue through the combined catalog so ambiguity and completed-inspection behavior remain unchanged. Ambiguous prefixes use the existing-style ambiguity diagnostic. A completed backend row with no checkpoints or no usable retained stage conversation is hidden from the picker; an explicit target reports that it is stale or missing required durable checkpoint/session data. A completed run remains inspectable when at least one stage has a usable transcript; missing, empty, directory, context-empty, or partially malformed transcript paths are omitted from stage chat attachment. Validation uses the final retained transcript for a repeated stage replay key, so an obsolete superseded checkpoint path does not hide an otherwise valid completed run. Reopening inspection refreshes a changed authoritative retained-chat handle. Session-cache-only rows are likewise hidden because the backend is authoritative. Cancelled, killed, non-resumable failed, and other terminal non-success states are never added. Normal /resume, atomic -r, and --continue behavior for internal workflow stage sessions is unchanged.

Cancellation, failure, and retry semantics

Configuring DBOS/Postgres

DBOS/Postgres durability requires no setup on supported local platforms. To use an existing Postgres database, set DBOS_SYSTEM_DATABASE_URL before starting Atomic; otherwise Atomic provisions embedded Postgres (with drop-privilege support when running as root on Linux), with Docker as a platform fallback. The DBOS SDK ships with @bastani/atomic. If no durable backend can be provisioned, workflows run on a process-local in-memory backend with a loud non-durable warning — never on the legacy per-workflow file store under ~/.atomic/workflow-durable — and cross-process resume is unavailable until Postgres provisioning is fixed.
When /workflow resume lists or resumes a DBOS-backed workflow in a fresh process, Atomic first hydrates its in-memory replay mirror from DBOS. Atomic stores checkpoints as structured, versioned DBOS outputs containing the checkpoint kind, id, tool argument hash, UI prompt hash, stage replay key, completed output, and additive versioned stage-topology metadata when available, so replay can skip completed ctx.tool, ctx.ui, ctx.stage, ctx.task, ctx.chain, ctx.parallel, and ctx.workflow work without relying on prior in-process state and completed inspection can rebuild the original DAG. Atomic updates the in-memory replay mirror for awaited DBOS checkpoints only after DBOS accepts the write, and root metadata is mirrored as versioned DBOS records where the latest timestamp wins during hydration. Unmarked raw-output checkpoint records remain readable as generic stage checkpoints when their workflow has compatible current metadata; marked envelopes with unsupported envelope versions are ignored rather than decoded as raw output, while unsupported or malformed additive topology fields are ignored without dropping an otherwise valid stage envelope. Atomic does not use the legacy file backend under ~/.atomic/workflow-durable; cross-session /workflow resume reads DBOS only.

Workflow Locations

Atomic discovers workflow definitions in this order: A workflow module may export one default workflow definition and/or named workflow definitions. Discovery checks the default export first, then named exports. Discovery validates every runtime export of a discovered workflow file as a workflow definition. Discovery rejects a named export that is not a workflow definition — a widget factory, shared constant, or utility function — with an INVALID_DEFINITION discovery diagnostic (export is not an object), even when the module also has a valid default export (the valid workflow still loads; the diagnostic flags the extra export as skipped). TypeScript erases type-only exports (export type / export interface) at runtime, so discovery never flags them. To co-locate reusable helpers with your workflows — for example a ctx.ui.custom<T> widget factory you want to import in tests without running the workflow — put them in a subdirectory and import them from the workflow file. Discovery scans only the top level of each workflow directory, so subdirectories such as .atomic/workflows/lib/ are never treated as workflow modules:
Atomic loads workflow files with jiti, so TypeScript works without compilation.

Reloading workflow resources

Run /workflow reload after adding, editing, renaming, or deleting workflow modules or changing workflow config. Reload rescans project and user conventional directories, legacy .pi locations, configured file/directory paths, and package resources without restarting Atomic. The workflow tool’s reload action uses the same in-process path. Reload builds a complete replacement registry before publishing it. Concurrent requests are serialized and coalesced, stale discovery from an earlier session cannot overwrite newer state, and a fatal refresh failure retains the previous registry. Reload is safe while workflows are running: existing runs keep the definition and runtime snapshot they started with, while subsequent list/get/inputs/help/completion/invocation calls use the newly published registry. The /workflow argument-completion popup reads that same live registry. Project, user, package-provided, and built-in workflow names therefore appear immediately after reload both after /workflow and after /workflow inputs ; restarting Atomic is not required. A successful rescan may still contain per-resource diagnostics. Both reload surfaces show CONFIG_INVALID, IMPORT_FAILED, INVALID_DEFINITION, PATH_NOT_FOUND, and duplicate-name diagnostics instead of reporting bare success while silently skipping a resource. Valid sibling workflows remain available. Fix the reported source/path and reload again; no process restart is required.

Workflow Configuration

Configured workflow paths live in workflow extension config. Project config paths are relative to the project root. Global config paths are relative to ~/.atomic/agent. Project config:
Global config:
Example config:
Runtime config defaults: Invalid JSON or invalid shapes produce CONFIG_INVALID diagnostics. Missing config files are ignored.

Settings

Settings can list package sources directly:
Use object form to filter which workflows load from a package:
workflows patterns follow package filtering rules:
  • Omit workflows to load every workflow allowed by the package manifest.
  • Use [] to load no workflows from that package.
  • Use !pattern to exclude matches.
  • Use +path to force-include an exact path.
  • Use -path to force-exclude an exact path.
Run atomic config to enable or disable package resources interactively. Atomic saves workflow package filters as workflows patterns in settings.

Package Setup

Atomic packages can ship workflows through package metadata or conventional directories. A package manifest can declare workflows next to extensions, skills, prompt templates, and themes:
Paths are relative to the package root and may use glob patterns. Include atomic-package for Atomic package discovery and pi-package for compatibility with existing package-gallery tooling. For new Atomic package examples, prefer atomic.workflows and atomic.extensions. pi.workflows and pi.extensions remain supported for compatibility with existing packages. Workflows can be declared with atomic.workflows or discovered from conventional workflows/ / workflow/ directories. Unlike other resource types, package workflows still fall back to conventional directories when a package manifest exists but omits the workflow key. App-level config prefers atomicConfig where available; legacy piConfig is still read as a shim. Convention directory example:
Install packages globally or locally:
By default, atomic install writes to global settings (~/.atomic/agent/settings.json). Use -l to write to project settings (.atomic/settings.json). A team can commit project settings to share the same workflow package set. To try a package for one run, use --extension or -e:
Workflow stage sessions inherit the same package and temporary -e resource discovery snapshot as the main chat. That means a workflow loaded from an external package or directory can start stages that see the package’s extensions/tools, subagents and agent definitions, skills, prompt templates, themes, workflows, and trusted borrowed project-local resources without sharing the parent chat’s resource-loader instance. Passing an explicit resourceLoader in stage options still opts that stage out of this inheritance.

Programmatic Usage

@bastani/workflows is an Atomic package extension. It registers:
  • /workflow <name> key=value ... for interactive named runs
  • /workflow connect|attach|pause|interrupt|quit|resume|status|inputs|reload for live control, inspection, and rediscovery
  • the workflow tool for named execution, discovery, inspection, messaging, run control, and reload
The signatures in this reference follow the externally shipped standalone authoring declaration in packages/workflows/src/authoring.ts. Atomic’s internal runtime types may specialize opaque SDK values or add executor-only integration fields; those are not ordinary workflow-package authoring API. Workflow definition files must export definitions produced by workflow({...}). Keep non-workflow runtime helpers (widget factories, shared utilities) in a subdirectory the discovery scan ignores, such as .atomic/workflows/lib/ — see Workflow Locations. The former imperative object-form runner is not part of the public SDK, and authored workflow files cannot use runWorkflow as a runner from @bastani/workflows. Standalone TypeScript workflow packages type-check the SDK import without a hand-authored .d.ts, declare module shim, or tsconfig paths alias. The SDK types ship with @bastani/atomic, so a workflow package depends only on @bastani/atomic (plus a typebox peer):
Workflow SDK type resolution depends on the package’s other imports:
  • A package that imports @bastani/atomic anywhere (for example, an extension shipped in the same package) automatically resolves the workflow SDK types. @bastani/atomic’s root declarations reference the ambient bridge, so no extra configuration is needed.
  • A pure workflow-only package — one that imports nothing but @bastani/workflows — adds a single opt-in so TypeScript loads the ambient bridge. Set it once for the project in tsconfig.json:
    or add a single reference directive at the top of one workflow file:
Either form makes import { workflow } from "@bastani/workflows" import { Type } from "typebox" and the @bastani/workflows/builtin/* composition imports resolve under tsc (moduleResolution: NodeNext) with no hand-authored .d.ts, no declare module shim, and no paths alias. @bastani/workflows is not a separate npm package — its types ship with @bastani/atomic — so list both @bastani/atomic and typebox (workflow files import Type from typebox) in peerDependencies. Runtime discovery and loading via atomic.workflows are unchanged: Atomic’s loader still supplies the SDK when workflow files execute.

workflow(spec)

Creates the frozen branded definition documented in The workflow() Definition. Discovery accepts only definitions minted by this function.

createRegistry(initial?)

Creates an immutable-style registry keyed by normalized workflow name. register, merge, and remove return registries rather than mutating the current registry.

run(definition, inputs, opts?)

Executes a compiled definition programmatically with validated inputs. Empty-input workflows accept an empty readonly record.

RunOpts

Supplies runtime adapters, execution policy, persistence, MCP, cancellation, graph/store integration, continuation metadata, and lifecycle callbacks to run(...). Every field is optional. The public authoring declaration intentionally excludes runtime-only executor fields such as defaultSessionDir, gitWorktreeSetupCache, durableBackend, durableScope, and onStageSession.

resolveInputs(schema, provided)

Applies schema defaults and validates the provided input record, returning typed resolved values. The function rejects invalid provided values.

setupGitWorktree(options)

Synchronously creates or validates a reusable worktree and remaps the cwd. It applies the same validation, symlink-preserving path handling, and cwd-preservation behavior as workflow stages.

normalizeWorkflowName(name) / workflowNamesEqual(a, b)

Normalization trims and lowercases, converts whitespace and underscores to hyphens, removes other characters, collapses hyphens, and trims edge hyphens. Equality compares normalized names.

GraphFrontierTracker

Tracks inferred DAG parents from JavaScript execution order. It is a low-level engine utility for integrations that need the same frontier semantics as the workflow executor.

Execution policies

The exported frozen policies define the standard interactive and headless behavior. Each constant satisfies WorkflowExecutionPolicy.

createStore() / store

createStore() returns an isolated workflow state store. store is the default singleton exported by the SDK authoring surface. This is the stable core exposed by the standalone authoring declaration. Atomic’s runtime store also has graph, prompt, session, pause/resume, snapshot, and subscription methods used by embedded integrations; those richer runtime controls are not part of the lean workflow-package Store contract shown here.

createCancellationRegistry() / cancellationRegistry

The factory creates an isolated registry; cancellationRegistry is the default singleton. Aborts signal registered controllers and children rather than killing processes.

Static / TSchema

These TypeBox types are re-exported for authoring helpers. The runtime Type builder is not re-exported; import it from typebox.

runWorkflow (removed)

This runtime migration stub exists only so old modules fail at the callsite with a clear error. Use workflow({...}) for authoring and run(...) for programmatic execution.

Builtin workflow exports

Each builtin is a workflow definition. The barrel and individual module paths also export the six pattern workflows documented below. See Compose with builtin workflows for the import table and a parent workflow example.

Fast Inference for Workflow Stages

Workflow stages can use faster, higher-priority inference on supported providers so multi-stage runs finish sooner. Codex fast mode currently provides this option.

Codex fast mode

Use /fast to manage Codex fast mode separately for normal chat and workflow-stage sessions. The settings are codexFastMode.chat and codexFastMode.workflow; workflow stages use the workflow scope, not the chat scope. Fast mode is eligible only for supported openai/* and openai-codex/* providers. It does not apply to github-copilot/*, Azure OpenAI, OpenRouter, or custom OpenAI-compatible providers. When Atomic applies fast mode, workflow stage displays keep the raw model id and expose fast as a separate marker/stage metadata indicator. Enable workflow fast mode deliberately for broad workflows: parallel fan-out and fallback attempts can multiply priority-tier requests and cost.

Context Engineering

A workflow is an information-flow system, not just a list of prompts. Most workflow failures come from missing, stale, oversized, or poorly-routed context. Design every stage boundary deliberately.

Locally Scoped Stage Prompts

Stage prompts should define local contracts, not describe the full workflow runtime. Write prompts as if the stage could be executed independently from a fresh session with only the listed inputs. Include:
  • the stage’s current objective and what is out of scope for this stage
  • the exact files, artifacts, child outputs, or user inputs it may use
  • the expected output format, or the schema it must return when the workflow item is schema-enabled
  • the checks, tools, or deterministic commands it should run when relevant
  • the success criteria that let this stage stop
Avoid unrelated workflow internals such as reducer algorithms, future PR stages, sibling reviewer names, loop implementation details, or project-specific nicknames unless they are explicitly part of the current stage contract. If a term such as a gate name, ledger field, or workflow nickname is necessary, define it in the prompt before using it. Choose context mode deliberately. Use context: "fork" or forkFromSessionFile for coherent long-running implementation stages that need continuity from their own earlier work. Use context: "fresh" for unbiased reviewer, evaluator, and gate stages so they inspect the current files and explicit artifacts rather than inheriting the implementer’s assumptions. When continuity is needed across fresh stages, pass it explicitly through files, declared outputs, and reads.

Context-Mode-Aware Prompt Text

Context mode is an execution property configured with context/forkFromSessionFile; the model cannot act on context mode, so keep it out of prompt text:
  • Never describe the stage’s own context mode. Sentences like “you are running in a fresh context window”, “your context is clean/non-forked”, or “this is a forked session” add tokens without changing behavior. State the concrete action, inputs, and success criteria instead.
  • Fresh stages must not reference invisible context. A fresh stage has no “previous conversation”, cannot see sibling stages, and does not know the surrounding graph, so instructions like “compare against previous workflow reasoning” or “this runs in parallel with the locator pass” do not help and may confuse the model. Phrase the same intent stage-locally (“compare the working tree against the baseline branch”; “do your own scan; do not assume any other stage’s output is available”) and pass any state the stage needs through files, declared outputs, and reads.
  • Forked continuation prompts send only the delta. A forked stage already carries the role, contracts, guidance, and output format from its own earlier prompts, so repeating them uses more tokens and can make the two copies diverge. Send what changed since the fork point — new artifacts, updated state, the next action — plus a one-line pointer back (“the contracts and report format established earlier in this thread still apply unchanged”) instead of re-injecting the full text.
  • Keep one canonical copy of shared contracts. When fresh and forked variants of a stage share guidance, render the full contract only in the prompt that first establishes it and reference it from continuations. If a continuation needs a contract restated (for example, after a schema change), that is a new contract version, not a repeat.
The builtin goal and ralph workflows follow this pattern: their first worker/orchestrator prompts include the full contracts, while forked continuation turns send only the per-turn state (new receipts, the latest review artifacts, the rewritten research file) with a pointer back to the established guidance.

Context Fundamentals

Treat context as a finite attention budget. Include only information needed for the current decision, place critical constraints near the beginning or end of prompts, and use progressive disclosure instead of loading every possible reference up front. Common context sources:
  • System instructions: persistent behavior and guardrails.
  • User inputs: workflow inputs and human-in-the-loop decisions.
  • Retrieved documents: files, search results, logs, API responses, and artifacts.
  • Message history: useful for continuity, but grows quickly in long-running stages.
  • Tool outputs: often the largest source of context bloat.
For long workflows, assume effective model performance degrades before the advertised context limit. Keep high-signal summaries and artifact references close to the stage that needs them.

Context Degradation Patterns

Watch for these failure modes in long or multi-stage workflows: Use compaction, file references, and bounded loops before context fills with transcript noise. In attached workflow stage chat, manual compaction shows Compacting context..., threshold compaction shows Auto-compacting..., and overflow recovery shows Context overflow detected. Auto-compacting... in the same animated status row used for normal model work. A successful compaction leaves the normal expandable ✻ Context compacted boundary in the transcript; the boundary is reconstructed from the durable session and has a typed live fallback if the refreshed session snapshot is temporarily unavailable.

Compression and Artifact Handoffs

Optimize for tokens per completed task, not the smallest prompt. Aggressive compression can force later stages to rediscover information. A compressed handoff includes:
  • objective and current status
  • decisions already made
  • files, symbols, commands, and artifact paths with evidence
  • open questions and known risks
  • rejected alternatives when they matter
  • next action expected from the downstream stage
Use output, outputMode: "file-only", and reads for large research bundles, logs, or reviewer outputs. Keep summaries compact and let downstream stages read full artifacts only when needed. In the downstream stage prompt, say Read the file at ${artifactPath} before continuing. Do not inject full session tails, all previous stage outputs, or every prior review round into later prompts by default; pass the latest relevant artifact paths and make older history discoverable from a ledger or index file. Substantial handoffs should travel through files or durable artifacts instead of hidden transcript assumptions. This keeps stage prompts small, makes review/audit possible, and lets later stages reread the authoritative material without depending on what a previous model summarized.

Multi-Agent and Parallel Patterns

Use parallel stages to isolate context and separate independent work, not merely to assign role labels. Good parallel branches have distinct evidence-gathering or review angles:
  • locator / mapper: where relevant files and systems live
  • analyzer: how the current implementation works
  • pattern finder: how similar code is written elsewhere
  • external researcher: what upstream docs or APIs require
  • reviewer/evaluator: whether outputs satisfy the validation contract
Have the parent workflow synthesize results rather than letting branches silently make conflicting decisions. If branches must agree, design an explicit consensus or adjudication stage.

Filesystem Context

Use files when workflow context grows too large:
Recommended patterns:
  • write large tool outputs to files and return concise references
  • store plans, state, and reviewer findings in structured markdown or JSON
  • pass artifact paths via reads; prompt agents with Read the file at <path>... rather than pasting artifacts into {previous}
  • for review loops, pass the latest review-round artifact first and let a ledger/index point to older rounds only when needed
  • give parallel branches separate output paths to avoid write conflicts
  • use grep, globbing, and line-range reads instead of loading entire logs
  • clean scratch files or keep them under run-specific directories

Evaluation and Quality Gates

Build validation into the workflow instead of waiting for a final manual check. Useful gates include:
  • deterministic checks: tests, typechecks, linters, schema validation, command exit codes
  • rubric checks: completeness, correctness, evidence quality, risk coverage, user fit
  • reviewer stages: fresh-context reviewers that inspect artifacts and current files
  • LLM-as-judge stages: direct scoring, pairwise comparison, or rubric-based grading for subjective outputs
Prefer schema-enabled workflow items for model review and gate decisions. Atomic passes the schema directly to the final-answer tool and captures the tool arguments; it no longer adds separate structured-output parsing, object-root restrictions, or sidecar validation. Object-shaped decision schemas with explicit booleans/enums, findings arrays, confidence, evidence fields, and error reporting are usually easiest to consume, but array or primitive schemas are valid when they fit the handoff. Avoid brittle regular-expression matching against free-form prose such as “looks good”, “approved”, or “PASS”. Use small dedicated model stages for adaptive gates when deterministic code alone cannot decide what to check. For example, a stage can read an artifact, inspect the repo, run a named tool or command, and then emit a structured decision by configuring schema on that workflow item. Keep that stage’s prompt narrow: tell it the specific check to perform, the files/tools it may use, and the structured decision it must return. When using LLM judges, reduce bias by defining score anchors, asking for evidence, calibrating against examples, and keeping length/order effects in mind. Track pass rates and failures over time for reusable workflows.

Tools, MCP, Memory, and Hosted Execution

Constrain each stage to the tools it needs. Too many tools increase ambiguity and token cost; too few tools force brittle workarounds. Tool descriptions should make inputs, side effects, and error handling clear. Use per-stage mcp allow/deny lists when a workflow needs external systems but some stages should remain read-only or isolated. Use memory or durable project knowledge only when cross-run continuity is required; otherwise prefer explicit inputs and artifacts. Hosted or remote agent workflows need additional design work: sandbox setup, dependency caching, auth boundaries, artifact transfer, concurrency limits, and multiplayer/session handoff behavior. Optimize startup before the user begins the run; do not make each stage rebuild its environment.

Task Fit and Project Design

Before turning a process into a workflow, confirm that it suits automation: For complex workflows, structure the implementation as a pipeline: acquire context, prepare prompts/artifacts, process with LLM stages, parse or validate outputs, and render the final result.

Migrating from the defineWorkflow() Builder API

#1457 removed the chained builder API — defineWorkflow(name).description(...).input(...).output(...).worktreeFromInputs(...).run(...).compile() — and made the single workflow({ name?, description, inputs, outputs, run }) object form the only authoring API. There is no shim and no deprecation period: workflow files that still call defineWorkflow(...).compile() fail discovery with a module-load error until authors migrate them. Use this section for workflow files that use the previous API. If you are authoring a new workflow, skip it and start from Writing a Workflow.

What changed

  • import { defineWorkflow, Type } from "@bastani/workflows"workflow now comes from @bastani/workflows, and Type comes from the typebox package directly. @bastani/workflows no longer re-exports Type. The Static and TSchema type exports are still re-exported from @bastani/workflows, so import type { Static } from "@bastani/workflows" keeps working — only the runtime Type builder moved.
  • The fluent builder chain became one object literal passed to workflow({ ... }).
  • name moved from the defineWorkflow(name) argument into the object. It is now optional — omit it and discovery derives the name from the filename (the recommended style used by the builtins and most examples), or keep it when you want the name to differ from the file’s basename.
  • outputs is now required. Workflows that declared no outputs before must now pass outputs: {}.
  • .compile() is gone. workflow({ ... }) returns the frozen, branded definition directly; export default it.
  • The imperative object-form runWorkflow(...) runner is also removed (it is a never placeholder that throws on access). Programmatic execution uses the exported run(def, inputs) helper or a registry — see Programmatic Usage.

Builder method → object key

ctx and every primitive (ctx.task, ctx.chain, ctx.parallel, ctx.stage, ctx.workflow, ctx.exit, ctx.ui) are unchanged, so you do not need to rewrite workflow bodies — only the authoring wrapper changes.

Full before / after

Before (removed API):
After (current API):

Conversion checklist

For each .atomic/workflows/*.ts (or workflow-package) file:
  1. Swap the import to import { workflow } from "@bastani/workflows" and add import { Type } from "typebox". Drop defineWorkflow from the @bastani/workflows import. import type { Static, TSchema } can stay on the @bastani/workflows import if you use those types.
  2. Replace defineWorkflow("<name>") with workflow({. You may keep name: "<name>" or drop the key entirely to derive the name from the filename.
  3. Move .description("<text>") to a description: "<text>", property.
  4. Collect every .input(key, schema) into one inputs: { key: schema, ... }, map.
  5. Collect every .output(key, schema) into one outputs: { key: schema, ... }, map. If there were no .output(...) calls, add outputs: {}, — it is now required.
  6. Move .worktreeFromInputs(binding) to a worktreeFromInputs: binding, property (same binding shape, unchanged).
  7. Move the .run(fn) callback to a run: fn, property; keep the body byte-for-byte identical.
  8. Delete the trailing .compile(), close the object with }), and keep export default.
  9. Run /workflow reload (or restart Atomic) and /workflow list to confirm the file loads. Because ctx and its primitives are unchanged, stage behavior, graph layout, resume/quit, and human-input prompts are unaffected.

Gotchas

  • outputs is required. The old .output(...) calls were optional, and a workflow without outputs compiled successfully. The new object form throws workflow: outputs must be a schema map when outputs is missing, so declare outputs: {} for outputless workflows.
  • Type is no longer re-exported. import { Type } from "@bastani/workflows" fails type-checking; import it from typebox instead. (Static and TSchema types are still re-exported from @bastani/workflows, so those imports do not need to change.)
  • .compile() does not exist. Leaving it produces a runtime TypeError; workflow({ ... }) already returns the frozen, branded definition.
  • name is derived from the filename when omitted. Discovery derives the name from the filename: review-changes.ts becomes review-changes, so an explicit name is only needed when it should differ from the basename.
  • Do not construct definitions manually. Discovery rejects hand-built objects carrying __piWorkflow: true, and ctx.workflow(...) rejects them too. Both accept only definitions minted by workflow({ ... }).
  • The imperative runWorkflow runner is gone. It is now a never placeholder that throws on access; use the exported run(def, inputs) helper or a registry for programmatic execution.
  • Keep outputs inline for the strictest type checking. The old builder enforced no-extra-output keys through a NoExtraOutputs generic on .run(fn); the object form re-creates that check for inline outputs maps, but cannot recover output keys when a schema map is widened or built up before being passed to workflow({ ... }). Keep the outputs literal inline so the declared-key check stays exact.
Everything else — stage primitives, ctx.inputs typing, runtime validation, DAG inference, MCP scoping, resume/quit, worktree binding, model fallback, and the /workflow tool contract — is unchanged.

Design Checklist

Before implementing or shipping a non-trivial workflow, answer these questions:
  • Purpose and fit: What concrete outcome should the workflow produce? Is the task naturally multi-stage, parallel, resumable, or reusable? What is out of scope?
  • Inputs: Which values should be declared as inputs? What is the narrowest schema type? Which defaults are safe?
  • Common pattern: Which common workflow pattern best matches the task, and where does the actual design intentionally diverge?
  • Stage decomposition: For each stage, what question does it answer, what context does it need, what output should it return, and what model/tool/MCP requirements does it have?
  • Local stage contract: Can this stage prompt stand alone with its current objective, inputs/artifacts, expected outputs, tools/checks, and success criteria, without unexplained workflow internals or future-stage assumptions?
  • Prompt vocabulary: Do stage, reviewer, and reducer prompts describe the concrete action, available evidence, and success criteria that the stage can see locally, instead of assuming the model knows the workflow graph’s name or surrounding context? Avoid phrasing like “the create-PR workflow stage” or “this Foo workflow” unless that name is explicitly supplied as user-visible context or materially affects behavior.
  • Information flow: For every edge between stages, is previous enough, or should the handoff use structured returns, files, reads, output, or outputMode?
  • Output contract: Which outputs should be declared in outputs, which stage/task/child results should run return for those keys, and what runtime type must each value have? If another workflow may call this workflow as a child, which non-default outputs should the parent rely on?
  • Context size: Can downstream stages succeed from the handoff alone? Should large transcripts, logs, or research bundles be summarized or saved as artifacts?
  • Control flow: Should the workflow use ctx.chain, ctx.parallel, ctx.ui, bounded loops, failFast, or fallbackModels?
  • User experience: Are stage names readable in status and graph views? Is the final output compact? Are important artifacts saved with stable paths?
  • Validation: What success criteria, review gates, deterministic checks, or evaluator stages prove the workflow did the right thing? Are model gates schema-backed instead of regex/prose-matched, and do adaptive gates run as focused model stages with explicit tool/check instructions?
  • Final actions: Does the workflow distinguish implementation/review convergence from post-approval final actions such as PR/MR/review creation, release tagging, deployment, or publication? Are reviewers and reducers prompted to approve and hand off when implementation and validation criteria are proven and only an explicitly authorized final action remains?
Good workflows are information-flow systems, not just prompt sequences. Keep stage prompts focused, preserve evidence with file paths or artifacts, and pass only the context each downstream stage needs.

Common Mistakes

  • Do not invent workflow names; list first.
  • Do not guess input keys; inspect with inputs or get first.
  • Do not call create, update, or delete on the workflow tool; definitions are code-authored.
  • Do not use legacy workflow tool fields like agent, stage, or run-control name.
  • Do not pass strings such as "goal" or path objects to ctx.workflow(...); import the workflow definition from @bastani/workflows/builtin or another TypeScript module first.
  • Do not rely on undeclared child outputs; returning a key that is not declared in outputs fails the run. Declare every child-workflow field you expose in outputs — including result — and return values matching those schemas from run (see Outputs).
  • Do not expect to select or rename child outputs at the call site; parent workflows receive the child’s declared output contract as child.outputs after checking child.exited === false, and a partial declared-output map when child.exited === true.
  • Do not expect named workflow runs to block the chat turn; they are background tasks.
  • Use interrupt or pause when the user asks to pause specific live work resumably; use quit for a graceful run-level process boundary.
  • Keep stage names readable because they appear in workflow status and UI.
  • Do not ask a stage to reason from workflow or stage names that are only orchestration labels. Model stages see their local prompt/artifacts/tools; describe the action to perform and the evidence to use (review the current code delta, create/update the review request) instead of relying on labels such as this Goal run or the Ralph reviewer — see the prompt-vocabulary item in the Design Checklist.
  • Do not write stage prompts that depend on hidden workflow-wide awareness; make each model stage locally scoped and self-described (Locally Scoped Stage Prompts).
  • Do not parse model gate decisions from ad-hoc prose with regular expressions; configure schema on a focused workflow item and consume result.structured.
  • Do not make reviewers fail an implementation gate solely because an authorized final action has not run yet. Represent that remainder as a post-approval next action (for example finalActionRemaining / nextAction) and let the final stage perform it.
  • Return compact structured decisions and save large artifacts to files; artifact handoffs should still use files when the next stage does not need the whole payload in context.
These mistakes cover workflow tool usage and authoring. For run-prompt anti-patterns, see the Anti-patterns table in Workflow Best Practices.

Workflow Best Practices

This playbook helps coding agents and workflow systems produce better results. Treat an agent as a capable engineering partner that needs a clear objective, tight scope, explicit validation, and occasional steering. Most weak agent runs fail for predictable reasons: the goal is vague, the scope is too broad, validation is missing, or the agent keeps following the wrong signal. This playbook addresses these failure modes. The examples below are synthetic and intentionally generic. Replace placeholders like [component], [test command], and [workflow] with your own project details.

The core loop

The core workflow pattern is:
Use this sequence:
  1. Define the end state.
  2. Constrain the blast radius.
  3. State what counts as done.
  4. Run the agent or workflow.
  5. Inspect status before reading details.
  6. Steer only when the run is off track, blocked, or missing criteria.
  7. Require evidence before accepting the result.
  8. Ask for a summary, handoff, or next-step plan.
A good workflow prompt states both the task and its success criteria.

Prompt anatomy

A strong workflow prompt usually includes:

Objective

What should be true when the work is complete?

Context

What does the agent need to know before acting?

Scope

What is the agent allowed to change?

Non-goals

What should the agent avoid?

Done criteria

How will we know the work is complete?

Stop conditions

When should the agent stop and ask instead of guessing?

Core principles

1. Start with the end state

Describe what should be true at the end, not just what the agent should investigate. Bad:
Better:

2. Keep scope tight

Agents often expand into nearby cleanup, which can help, but most workflow runs should stay bounded. Use phrases like:
  • Only touch files required for this behavior.
  • Do not refactor unrelated code.
  • Preserve existing behavior for [case].
  • Make the smallest correct change.

3. Separate implementation from validation

Relevant evidence, not the agent’s claim, determines whether a change is done. Evidence can include:
  • a targeted test,
  • a broader regression test,
  • a smoke command,
  • a typecheck or lint command,
  • a structured output contract check,
  • or a clear manual verification step.

4. Prefer evidence over speculation

When something fails, steer the agent back to the observable signal: the error, failing test, log line, user behavior, or broken contract.

5. Use staged thinking

For ambiguous work, separate the flow into stages:
If the cause is not clear, do not let the agent make broad, speculative changes.

6. Steer, do not micromanage

The best steering messages are short and corrective. They add constraints, redirect attention, or provide a decision. Usually, state only what changed instead of rewriting the whole prompt.

7. Treat failed validation as the next task

A failed test becomes the next objective.

8. Interrupt stale or wrong work

If a run is solving the wrong problem, based on outdated assumptions, or duplicating another run, stop it. Continuing usually creates more cleanup.

9. Inspect at the right level

For long-running workflows, do not start by reading every log. Check:
  1. overall status,
  2. current stage,
  3. blocker or failure reason,
  4. relevant stage details only if needed.

10. Ask for synthesis before handoff

Before switching from investigation to implementation, or from implementation to review, ask for a concise synthesis:

Common Workflow Patterns

For workflows larger than one tracked task, choose a small control-flow pattern before writing prompts. Workflow authors should favor these common patterns by default: naming the pattern up front keeps the stage graph understandable, makes validation gates explicit, and helps reviewers see why work is split across model sessions. Reach for a bespoke structure only when none of these patterns fit. These patterns are composable and the headings below link to runnable builtins. For example, a migration workflow can nest fan-out-and-synthesize for call-site fixes, adversarial-verification per patch, and loop-until-done while tests still fail. Import and compose the builtin definitions instead of copying their prompts/graphs.

Pattern diagrams

1. Classify-and-act
Builtin definition and contracts: Six composable pattern builtins.
Best practices:
  • Make the classifier return a structured category and confidence, not free-form prose.
  • Keep each action branch isolated with the minimum tools and context it needs.
  • Add a fallback or human-input branch for low-confidence classifications.
2. Fan-out-and-synthesize
Builtin definition and contracts: Six composable pattern builtins.
Best practices:
  • Partition by files, sources, claims, candidates, or work items that can be evaluated independently.
  • Save each branch to a separate artifact and pass paths with reads instead of inlining all branch output.
  • Treat synthesis as a barrier: it waits for every branch, deduplicates, resolves conflicts, and cites evidence.
3. Adversarial verification
Builtin definition and contracts: Six composable pattern builtins.
Best practices:
  • Give verifiers fresh context and a concrete rubric with pass/fail evidence requirements.
  • Separate implementation or generation from independent judgment to reduce a model’s bias toward its own output.
  • Ask verifiers to find blockers and not rewrite the candidate unless you explicitly assign them to repair it.
4. Generate-and-filter
Builtin definition and contracts: Six composable pattern builtins.
Best practices:
  • Generate more candidates than you need, then filter hard by an explicit rubric.
  • Dedupe before judging so near-identical candidates do not dominate the shortlist.
  • Use this for exploration, naming, design options, hypotheses, and lightweight eval ideas.
5. Tournament
Builtin definition and contracts: Six composable pattern builtins.
Best practices:
  • Use pairwise comparison when absolute scores are noisy or subjective.
  • Randomize or balance presentation order where possible to reduce order bias.
  • Keep the judge rubric short and require rationale tied to observable criteria.
6. Loop until done
Builtin definition and contracts: Six composable pattern builtins.
Best practices:
  • Define both success and escape conditions before the loop starts.
  • Keep a durable ledger of attempted work, findings, failures, and validation evidence.
  • Bound loops by iterations, budget, or convergence criteria so exhausting a bound produces an inspectable failure instead of letting the loop continue indefinitely.

Choosing a common workflow pattern

  • Pick classify-and-act when routing correctness matters more than breadth.
  • Pick fan-out-and-synthesize when the work divides cleanly into independent slices.
  • Pick adversarial verification when the main risk is a plausible but wrong answer.
  • Pick generate-and-filter when output quality depends on exploring a large option space.
  • Pick tournament when multiple whole-solution strategies should compete under one rubric.
  • Pick loop until done when the workflow should continue until evidence says it is finished, not until a preselected number of stages completes.
Record the selected pattern in your spec or workflow README, then adapt the diagram to the stage graph. If the final design does not resemble any common pattern, explain why in the workflow’s design notes.

Steering patterns

Tighten scope

Signal: The agent starts expanding into adjacent cleanup, unrelated files, or broad refactors. Steer:
Why: Prevents risky changes and keeps the run reviewable.

Add missing done criteria

Signal: The agent has a plan, but no clear completion criteria. Steer:
Why: Makes completion verifiable.

Redirect an off-track stage

Signal: The workflow is investigating the wrong area or solving the wrong problem. Steer:
Why: Saves time and prevents wrong assumptions from compounding.

Respond to a blocked prompt

Signal: The workflow asks for approval, a choice, or clarification. Steer:
Why: Keeps the workflow unblocked without adding ambiguity.

Turn failed validation into the next task

Signal: Tests, typecheck, lint, build, or smoke checks fail. Steer:
Why: Prevents accepting partially working output.

Ask for synthesis

Signal: The workflow has gathered information, but the next action is unclear. Steer:
Why: Turns findings into a usable plan.

Pause, stop, or rerun

Signal: A run is stale, duplicated, superseded, or based on outdated assumptions. Steer:
Why: Avoids conflicting changes and wasted work.

Copy-paste templates

Start a workflow

Tighten scope

Add acceptance criteria

Redirect a stage

Handle failed validation

Ask for synthesis

Turn findings into implementation steps

Prepare a release gate


Concrete examples

Example 1: Fixing a failing test

Scenario: A package has one failing unit test after a recent change. Initial objective:
Steering message:
Validation: Run [targeted test command], then [nearby test command]. Outcome: Small fix applied, regression test passes, and the workflow reports exact commands and results.

Example 2: Repairing a workflow definition

Scenario: A custom workflow no longer returns the expected structured output. Initial objective:
Steering message:
Validation: Reload workflow, run minimal smoke input, inspect structured result. Outcome: Contract fixed, smoke test passes, and the workflow can be reused safely.

Example 3: Investigating before implementing

Scenario: A user-reported bug is ambiguous. Initial objective:
Steering message:
Validation: Add or run a reproduction test before changing code. Outcome: Clear implementation plan produced, then delegated as a scoped fix.

Anti-patterns

These anti-patterns target run prompts; Common Mistakes covers workflow tool and authoring mistakes.

Quick reference

Before starting a workflow, include:
  • Objective
  • Context
  • Scope
  • Non-goals
  • Done criteria
  • Validation command
  • Reporting requirements
  • Stop conditions
Before accepting a workflow result, ask:
  • What changed?
  • Why was this the right fix?
  • What evidence supports it?
  • Which commands were run?
  • What still might be risky?
  • Is anything blocked or unresolved?
Clearer prompts help agents produce better results.